Video: Is Geno Smith ready?

New York Jets rookie quarterback Geno Smith wants to be a starting quarterback in Week 1. But to accomplish that goal, he must show the maturity and ability needed to beat out two veterans (Mark Sanchez, David Garrard) with a lot of experience.

Does Smith have a chance and is he ready to learn? One NFL scout, for example, didn't give ESPNNewYork.com's Rich Cimini a glowing review.

ESPN's NFL analyst Mark Schlereth and Brian Dawkins discuss New York’s newest quarterback.