If McCown stays healthy all yr and they go .500 or better and miss top QBs prospects in draft what happens to QB position in '18? #jetsmail
— Kevh74 (@kevh74) October 20, 2017
@RichCimini: To paraphrase a line from Charles Dickens, it would be the best of times and the worst of times. An eight-win (or better) season would be quite an accomplishment for the organization, top to bottom, a terrific foundation in terms of roster development and culture change. It would be an unmistakable signal the franchise is heading in the right direction.
The downside (and this can't be understated) is they'd be back to square one at quarterback. They can't go into next season with the same trio -- McCown, Bryce Petty and Christian Hackenberg. Where's the hope? How do you sell that to your fan base? You can do it for a year, but not two.
You can't help but appreciate what McCown is doing this season, but the man is 38 years old and may want to get started on his coaching career. The Jets certainly can't hand the job to Petty or Hackenberg, based on what they've shown over the last two years. They'd be lucky to stick as backups.
The Jets need to acquire a proven starter or a young quarterback with a high ceiling -- i.e. one of the top college prospects. If they're picking in the middle of the first round, they'd have to pay an obscene price to jump up into the top two or three. Consider what the Los Angeles Rams gave up last year to draft Jared Goff. It was crazy steep.
Would the Jets do that for Sam Darnold, Josh Rosen or Josh Allen? Knowing how the Jets think, yes, I could absolutely see them trying to make that move. If not, they have to trade for Alex Smith or open the checkbook for a big-ticket free agent (Kirk Cousins?).
General manager Mike Maccagnan won't get too many more cracks at trying to fix this problem. For three years, he has relied on Band Aids and "maybes" at quarterback. Come the offseason, it'll be time to do something permanent.