The New York Jets were 57-55 in Mike Tannenbaum's seven years as general manager. There were some highs, such as back-to-back AFC title game appearances following the 2009 and 2010 seasons, and there were lows, such as trading for quarterback Tim Tebow and handing out a big contract extension to Mark Sanchez.
Tannenbaum's track record has come to the forefront in South Florida after the Miami Dolphins hired him as executive vice president of football operations this week to take over the front office. On Tuesday, Tannenbaum stood by his record in New York.
“When you look over the 16 years I was there and the seven years as GM, I am proud of our record,” Tannenbaum said on a conference call with the Miami media. “Not every pick worked out. It usually doesn’t. I go back to what I said earlier that I wouldn’t trade the last two years for anything. I’ve learned a lot. I’ve really had a chance to reflect and spend time with college coaches, basketball coaches, player procurement, be it whatever sport. There are a lot of different things you can learn.”
Here are several hits and misses during Tannenbaum’s tenure as Jets’ general manager from 2006 to 2012:
Tannenbaum usually shines in the first round. He has a list of home runs with New York’s top pick, which includes cornerback Darrelle Revis, defensive lineman Muhammad Wilkerson and D'Brickashaw Ferguson. Miami has a quality pick this year at No. 14 overall and needs to get this pick right.
On the flip side, Tannenbaum has a history of second-round busts. He drafted quarterback Kellen Clemons in the second round in 2006, offensive lineman Vladimir Ducasse in 2010 and receiver Stephen Hill in 2012. All three were didn't work out. Tannenbaum’s only good second-round pick during his seven-year as general manager was linebacker David Harris in 2007.
Tannenbaum struck gold on several trades and free agents that led to New York’s playoff success. Veteran acquisitions such as cornerback Antonio Cromartie, running back LaDainian Tomlinson, linebacker Bart Scott and receivers Santonio Holmes and Braylon Edwards helped fuel New York’s playoff runs in 2009 and 2010.
As we mentioned early, Tannenbaum does not have a good history identifying quarterbacks. Clemons was a bust in 2006. The Tim Tebow trade was inexplicable. However, the Sanchez pick is debatable. New York traded up in the first round (No. 5 overall) to get him and he helped get the Jets twice to the AFC title game. Those are positives. But Sanchez clearly didn’t improve and New York signed him to a contract extension that signaled the beginning of the end for Tannenbaum. However, the Dolphins already have their quarterback in place for at least next season in Ryan Tannehill.
Finally, the Vernon Gholston pick at No. 6 overall in 2008 may be the biggest stain on Tannenbaum's résumé. Gholston remains one of the worst NFL selections in the past decade. He flamed out in three seasons and has been out of the league since 2010.
As with most personnel bosses, there are hits and misses. The goal for Miami is that Tannenbaum builds on his strengths and learns from prior mistakes.
Tannenbaum said Dolphins general manager Dennis Hickey will retain control of the draft and personnel moves. But rest assured Tannenbaum will have his fingerprints on Miami's roster this upcoming season.
“Everybody’s going to have input, but ultimately who we pick and when we pick, the roster decision will rest with him,” Tannenbaum said of Hickey. “Again, I’ve seen him work. I know he’s a collaborative leader. That’s my belief.”