Posted by ESPN.com's James Walker
Brad from Atlanta had a great Derrick Mason-inspired idea for the latest edition of "Thought of the Day" in the AFC North. The question examines which player on each division team would hurt the most if he suddenly left.
Here were the best responses this week in our AFC North inbox:
Zach from West Des Moines, IA writes: Hey James! Keep up the great work on the blog! In response to your "Thought of the Day" this week, I'd thought I'd throw out four names to you. If I had to choose that guy on each team, I'd go with Carson Palmer for the Bengals. Like you said, Cincy couldn't deal without him last season. Ed Reed for the Ravens. Their pass defense would be nothing without him. My sleeper for the Steelers is Aaron Smith. When he went down two years ago, the run defense of my Steelers folded completely. This fact makes me nervous for the 2010 season. Moving on, for the Browns, I seriously have got nothing. Is there a guy? If I had to choose, Shaun Rogers?
Utsav from Baltimore writes: For my ravens, there is no question that losing a player such as Ed Reed would have a dramatic impact on our season. Though we have improved our secondary, we have the best ball-hawk in years. Losing Reed suddenly would then give offenses the opportunity to throw more deep balls without fear of an interception-just ask Tony Romo or Chad Pennington how different those games would have been without Reed playing safety. For a rival, I would say Carson Palmer. Just look at what happened last season. Now that he is healthy, the Bungels have become a playoff contender in most minds, which shows how important Palmer is to the team's success.
Eddie Kilroy from Brunswick, Ohio writes: Hey James! In response to the sudden retirement question, I believe I have a surprising pick on who would affect their team the most. I believe that if the Raven's Haloti Ngata were to retire tomorrow, the team would instantly turn into a 5-11 team next season. No offense to Ray Lewis or Ed Reed, who are GOING to be future HOFer's, but if the Raven's defense lose the big man on the line, there will be no way they could stop the run as well as they have in the past, ultimately leading to them sucking. Keep up the good work James.
Mike from Columbus, Ohio writes: Hey James, love the blog. I have bled Orange and Brown since my dad put a homemade mobile in my crib when I was a baby. And I would say that with the current state of the of my beloved Browns, it would appear that anyone could retire and not really hurt them. But I think the one player that would set this team back even further if he were to call it quits is Joe Thomas. This guy has made the pro bowl in his first two seasons and barring injury I think would continue to be a staple in Hawaii for years to come. Left tackles like him come along once every 10 years, and you are lucky if you can snatch them up. As for the other division teams I think the Steelers would be devastated if they lost James Harrison, this guy brings it all the time and never stops. I think the Bengals would be non-existent without Carson Palmer. I mean he is the only reason people are saying they might be the surprise team this year. And for the Ravens, I would call it a tie between Ed Reed and Terrell Suggs. Both of those guys in my mind are one of if not the best at their positions. Thanks. GO BROWNS!
Joe from Niagara Falls, NY writes: As a Bengals fan, we had the displeasure of watching last season without the one player we couldn't afford to lose, Carson Palmer. So the Bengals are easy. The Steelers would be lucky to win eight games without Big Ben. But they could survive a loss of James Harrison and still get pressure on the QB. The Ravens would take the biggest hit if they lost Ray Lewis. When Ray was out for most of 2002 and 2005, the Ravens really struggled to compete consistently. The Browns suck. They would go from a four win season in 2008 to a four win season in 2009 with the loss of Joe Thomas. This question doesn't apply to them because they don't have an elite player at a skill position.
Kevin from Chesapeake, Va. writes: My most irreplaceable player per team: 1) Cincinnati Bengals-- Carlson Palmer, already proven based on last season's four wins that the team goes nowhere without him. 2) Cleveland Browns--Braylon Edwards, the only legitimate WR left on the team. Without him the team becomes one dimensional and teams will certainly stack the line to stop the already suspect running attack. 3) Baltimore Ravens- Ray Lewis, without this emotional leader this team will undoubtedly falter, as was proven the last time he went down for an extended time. He demands more from this defense and gets it. 4) Pittsburgh Steelers--Troy Polamalu is the straw that stirs the drink. His versatility is unmatched and is what makes the defense supercharged. His absence for an extended time would be problematic for the overall efficiency of the defense.
Nick from Pittsburgh, Pa. writes: James, as a Steelers fan, this is a very interesting question. The Steelers have shown an uncanny ability to replace injured players. For every Joey Porter or Larry Foote that leaves, a James Harrison or Lawrence Timmons or LaMarr Woodley emerges. With Hines Ward declining, Santonio Holmes is filling his shoes. No one on the offensive line is skilled enough to leave a void. Even when Ben Roethlisberger went down, Charlie Batch and Byron Leftwich proved adequate replacements. The biggest void caused on the Steelers in recent memory was from the loss of DE Aaron Smith. When he is injured, the decline in production on the Steelers defense is immediately noticeable. However, because he is relatively unknown outside of the AFC North, it is not surprising that the effect of his absence is often overlooked.
Art from Denver, CO writes: James, for the Steelers and Ravens, I would definitely have to go with the QB. We have seen both teams be good but not get "all the way" without a good QB whereas they both seem to be able to plug in someone new into their defenses (i.e. they have a lot of depth) and still look good. Ben has obviously gotten the Steelers over the hump when it came to getting to and through the Super Bowl. And we all saw what a difference Flacco made to the Ravens last year. For the Bengals, I think the argument could be made for Carson Palmer. Last year gave us a pretty good look at that scenario, although with T.J. Houshmandzadeh this year, we will still have to see how good the offense can be. As for the Browns, I'm not sure there is just one player that you can single out. I'm not just picking on them because I'm a part of Steeler Nation, but I don't see any one player on their team that rises above all of the rest. I think that while they may have more trouble replacing certain players, they still wouldn't really be any worse off if they lost any particular person on the team right now.