Big Ten picks rewind: Week 10

Think Nebraska felt good after the Hail Mary against Northwestern? Brian Bennett felt even better. He might have earned a St. Elmo dinner from me on that one play.

Bennett's Nebraska selection gives him a one-game lead in the season standings. My only condition if he wins: he must grow a mustache like Jordan Westerkamp.

Week 10/Season record

Adam Rittenberg: 4-2/61-13

Brian Bennett: 5-1/62-12

Here's one final look at the Week 10 predictions from us and our guest prognosticator, Andrew Schout from Kansas City, Mo.

It's time to rewind ...

Illinois at Penn State

  • Bennett's pick: Penn State 42, Illinois 20

  • Rittenberg's pick: Penn State 38, Illinois 21

  • Actual score: Penn State 24, Illinois 17 (OT)

  • 20-20 hindsight: We both expected Bill O'Brien's Lions to have a much easier time with Illinois, which easily could have left Happy Valley with an upset victory. Both defenses performed better than anticipated. Penn State WR Allen Robinson had a huge day (11 receptions, 165 yards) but failed to record a touchdown (Bennett thought he'd have three). Lions RB Bill Belton (201 rush yards, 1 TD) exceeded my yards prediction by 70 but had one touchdown less than I thought he'd have.

Wisconsin at Iowa

  • Bennett's pick: Wisconsin 30, Iowa 20

  • Rittenberg's pick: Wisconsin 28, Iowa 21

  • Actual score: Wisconsin 28, Iowa 9

  • 20-20 hindsight: I nailed Wisconsin's score, but the Badgers needed a late surge to get there. Joel Stave connected with Jared Abbrederis for a touchdown in the third quarter, not the fourth, as I predicted. Stave finished with two touchdown strikes, one fewer than Bennett's forecast for him. Neither of us mentioned Wisconsin RB James White, who had a gritty performance, and we both expected more from the Iowa offense.

Ohio State at Purdue

  • Bennett's pick: Ohio State 56, Purdue 13

  • Rittenberg: Ohio State 48, Purdue 10

  • Actual score: Ohio State 56, Purdue 0

  • 20-20 hindsight: Bennett nailed Ohio State's score and had the Buckeyes scoring 21 points in the first 10 minutes (it took them 12 minutes, 23 seconds). Buckeyes QB Braxton Miller exceeded my prediction of three touchdown passes with four. We both incorrectly predicted Purdue would score, as the Boilers were blanked for the second consecutive game.

Minnesota at Indiana

  • Bennett's pick: Indiana 33, Minnesota 30

  • Rittenberg: Indiana 35, Minnesota 31

  • Actual score: Minnesota 42, Indiana 39

  • 20-20 hindsight: Our Indiana picks looked awful as Minnesota surged to a 35-31 advantage. Then we looked like geniuses as Indiana rallied to reclaim the lead. But Indiana once again found a way to stumble in crunch time, and our lack of faith in the Gophers cost us. I correctly pegged Hoosiers WRs Cody Latimer and Shane Wynn for long touchdown receptions (30 and 40 yards, respectively). Brian's forecast of a big game for Indiana QB Tre Roberson fell short, as Nate Sudfeld outplayed him. Minnesota's run game (248 yards) showed up, as I expected, but the Gophers' pass offense also stepped up behind QB Philip Nelson.

Michigan at Michigan State

  • Bennett's pick: Michigan State 17, Michigan 14

  • Rittenberg's pick: Michigan State 21, Michigan 17

  • Actual score: Michigan State 29, Michigan 6

  • 20-20 hindsight: Both of us went with Michigan State because of its defense but still gave Michigan's offense too much credit in the score predictions. I correctly pegged Spartans CB Darqueze Dennard for a fourth-quarter interception, but RB Jeremy Langford had only one rushing touchdown, not two. Michigan State LB Denicos Allen didn't have a pick-six, as Brian predicted, but he recorded two sacks and three tackles for loss, earning national defensive player of the week honors.

Northwestern at Nebraska

  • Bennett's pick: Nebraska 24, Northwestern 21

  • Rittenberg: Northwestern 27, Nebraska 24

  • Actual score: Nebraska 27, Northwestern 24

  • 20-20 hindsight: How about those score predictions? I had the right final score but the wrong winner. Brian had the right score but wrong winner if Northwestern knocks down the Hail Mary. Obviously, neither of us expected things to end the way they did. Huskers RB Ameer Abdullah (127 yards) came close to my rushing prediction (150 yards), and while Northwestern QB Kain Colter had a gutsy performance, he finished with zero touchdowns, not three.

You've seen how we fared. Now it's time to check on Andrew, who had a pretty nice weekend, as he got married and saw his Michigan State Spartans thump Michigan. Not too shabby.

Penn State 34, Illinois 24

Wisconsin 24, Iowa 17

Ohio State 48, Purdue 10

Indiana 41, Minnesota 38

Michigan State 27, Michigan 16

Nebraska 26, Northwestern 20

Andrew's picks mirrored Brian's, so he also went 5-1. Like ours, Andrew's score predictions need a little work, although he finished strong with the Nebraska-Northwestern one. If he had flipped Minnesota and Indiana he would have had a perfect week of picks.

Want to be this week's guest picker? Tell us why you should be the choice for Week 11 here and here (be sure to put "GUEST PICKS" in the body of your post).