Next up for Luck is Carolina quarterback Cam Newton, who beat Kansas City running back Jamaal Charles in the quarterfinals. Newton is in the running to become the first player to reach the finals of the cover voting for Madden twice.
The other semifinal matchup also features two of the NFL's best young players.
Voting for the semifinals runs through May 30, and the finals are May 30-June 6. The winner will be announced June 6 on "SportsCenter."