They did not win a Big Ten championship or play in a Rose Bowl. Their 34 wins in four years don't rank among the best records in school history, and most of those are unofficial victories, anyway.
Yet when Penn State honors its 30 outgoing seniors on Saturday before the Wisconsin game, it will be a highly emotional sendoff that's unlike any other senior day in the country. This group has created a unique legacy, one built not on wins and losses as much as loyalty, resilience and strength.
"They will always be remembered here for the leadership they showed," head coach Bill O'Brien said.
This class endured the strain of the Jerry Sandusky scandal and the death of beloved coach Joe Paterno. The defining moment for this group came this summer, when the NCAA handed down some of the harshest sanctions ever leveled against a football program. With no bowl possibilities and a free pass for transfers, the team could have easily crumbled.
But while some players did transfer, most of the seniors stayed. Led by Michael Mauti and Michael Zordich, they fiercely and now famously pledged their loyalty to the school with a public show of support. In doing so, they gave a fractured Nittany Lions fan base something to rally around.
"They were instrumental in keeping this football team together in the summer when the sanctions came out," O'Brien said. "They really helped the community move forward.
"They grew up a lot. That's a hard thing to deal with when you're in your early 20s. But these guys are a special group of guys."
While many predicted doom and gloom for this season after the sanctions and departures, the Nittany Lions will be looking to finish 8-4 with a win over the Badgers. Several seniors have played major roles in that, including Mauti, Zordich, quarterback Matt McGloin, linebacker Gerald Hodges, defensive tackle Jordan Hill, offensive linemen Mike Farrell and Matt Stankiewitch, cornerback Stephon Morris, defensive end Sean Stanley and others.
"The way we've approached it is just to play each and every game like it's our last," McGloin said. "We're just trying to leave our mark and mark sure we've left this place on a high note."
The one sour note about this week is that Mauti won't be able to play. The star linebacker became the face of this team in the summer with his outspoken comments about the sanctions and loyalty, and then he went out and put together a season worthy of All-America recognition.
But Mauti injured his left knee, the same one that kept him out of most of last season, last week versus Indiana. While the school hasn't released full details of the injury, it has said that Mauti's season is over.
"We've been going up to Mike and giving him comfort and letting him know he's not alone through this," Stankiewitch said. "He said, 'Let's finish this season out strong. Let's finish out with eight wins and not settle for anything less than a win.'"
An 8-4 season would be an excellent accomplishment for this team, but the achievement of these seniors goes deeper than that. They've shown there's still much to play for at Penn State despite the lack of a postseason reward. They've helped set the tone for the future of the program while preventing it from unraveling.
They've got one last game to play, and they deserve a rousing sendoff.
"We want to be remembered as a high-character team, a high-character class," Stankiewitch said. "We want to be remembered as staying together and performing every Saturday with an extreme amount of effort. We look at this game as an opportunity to show the nation even more how together we are as a team."