Eli vs. Big Ben? Give me Eli!

Posted by ESPN.com's Matt Mosley

Apparently an off-hand remark I made in a recent blog entry didn't sit well with the patrons of James Walker's excellent AFC North blog. And that's why James has challenged me to a mini-debate on the issue.

So who would you guys take? Eli Manning or Ben Roethlisberger? I'd like to hear arguments for both quarterbacks and then I'll deliver my speech later today. And yes, I'm planning to steal your material -- if it's decent.