Assuming the report is accurate, the Ravens are wrong to ask Boldin to reduce his $6 million salary this year after a remarkable playoff run by him just two months ago. And Baltimore would make a big mistake to cut Boldin because there is no one on the team who can replace him in the starting lineup or make the same tough, clutch catches. The deadline for Boldin's decision is Tuesday.
I understand the Ravens' need to create more salary-cap room. Baltimore is a projected $12 million under the cap, but the team may only have half that space after tendering its restricted free agents (tight ends Dennis Pitta and Ed Dickson as well as defensive lineman Art Jones). With that limited amount of cap room, it could be difficult for the Ravens to retain linebacker Dannell Ellerbe, the Ravens' top priority in free agency, and safety Ed Reed.
The Ravens obviously wouldn't ask Boldin to reduce his salary if they didn't have to do so. Boldin was a monster in the postseason, catching 22 passes for 380 yards receiving and four touchdowns. Still, how can you ask someone who averaged 95 yards receiving per game in the playoffs to give back money? I believe everyone would agree that Boldin has earned that money.
I would acknowledge there aren't many options for the Ravens to create more room. Boldin has the second-highest salary on the team in 2013, right behind linebacker Terrell Suggs ($6.4 million). I'm fairly certain the Ravens didn't ask Suggs to take a pay cut. The Ravens could restructure the contracts of guard Marshal Yanda ($4.5 million this year) and defensive tackle Haloti Ngata ($4 million), but as the Steelers know, that pushes the cap hit into future seasons. Baltimore could also free up $3 million by cutting fullback Vonta Leach, who had a decidedly smaller role in 2012.
The Ravens have made the tough calls in the past. They took heat when they parted ways with tight end Todd Heap and wide receiver Derrick Mason. Baltimore has since replaced them with tight end Pitta and wide receiver Torrey Smith. Unless the Ravens expect to find another Smith in the draft, it's not a clear choice on who would replace Boldin.
Even though Boldin hasn't put up the same numbers that he did when he was in Arizona, he still has led the Ravens in receiving yards in all three seasons in Baltimore. He is physical enough to pull down the catches in traffic in the end zone as well as the back-shoulder throw from Joe Flacco on a critical third down late in the Super Bowl.
The Ravens rewarded Flacco after his stellar performance in the playoffs. Now, they want to take money away from Boldin, who was a big factor in making Flacco look so good. Boldin, 32, has said he would retire if the Ravens cut him. Considering what Boldin has done for the Ravens, it would be a shame if it came down to that.