ALAMEDA, Calif. -- The loser of this Week 2 matchup will face some tough early-season consequences.
If the Oakland Raiders lose their home opener, they'll fall to 0-2, which will be difficult for their fan base to accept. The Raiders made a lot of changes this offseason. If Oakland drops another game, it will be difficult for a franchise that hasn’t had a winning record since 2002 to get to 9-7 or better this year.
If the Houston Texans lose to the Raiders and rookie quarterback Derek Carr, the Texans will have to deal with the reality that they passed on Carr in the second round before the Raiders took him at No. 36. Derek Carr is the younger brother of David Carr, the No. 1 overall pick by Houston in 2002. Derek Carr and his family moved to Houston to be with David, who flamed out with the Texans. Perhaps the Texans were afraid to sell the choice of another Carr to their fan base. If they lose this game, though, the Texans might face more questions.
Texans reporter Tania Ganguli and Raiders reporter Bill Williamson discuss the matchup:
Williamson: Tania, will the Texans regret not taking Carr?
Ganguli: They did a lot of work on Carr in the pre-draft process and liked him. Coach Bill O’Brien spoke very highly of Carr this week, too, saying he will be a good pro and the Raiders did a good job drafting him. He was then quick to say he also thinks Tom Savage, who the Texans drafted in the fourth round, was a good pick there. This is something I’ll definitely watch as the season goes on. The Raiders took Carr, who is obviously now their starting quarterback, three picks after the Texans selected guard Xavier Su'a-Filo with the first pick of the second round. The players are in different situations, so it’s not fair to directly compare them. Carr was there for the whole offseason, in a place where the starter was struggling tremendously. Su'a-Filo's arrival was delayed by the quarter-system rule; the NFL prohibits players from working out with their new teams until the player's academic calendar is complete. In the meantime, Ben Jones won the left guard job. Bill, why aren’t the Texans facing their former quarterback, Matt Schaub, who is now the Raiders' backup? How did he handle the Raiders' decision to start Carr?
Williamson: The Raiders figured Schaub would be a short-term answer, but he didn’t necessarily have what it takes to be a difference-maker who could win games. So Oakland decided to serve youth now with Carr. As far as how Schaub handled losing the starting job, he was terrific. This guy is a pro. Schaub admitted he wasn’t pleased with the move, but he handled it well. Carr has praised Schaub for offering to help in any way possible. Schaub’s actions have made the transition easier for everyone. Tania, Texans punter Shane Lechler, who was Oakland's punter for many years, is a Black Hole favorite. Is this a big game for him?
Ganguli: The Raiders' organization means a lot to Lechler. He appreciates Al Davis spending a fifth-round pick on him in 2000. He loved his 13 seasons there -- especially the Super Bowl season. But, like many players in this situation, he doesn’t want to draw too much attention to that. It helps that he faced the Raiders last season. It also helps that he barely knows anyone on the team anymore. Lechler said this week that he hopes to punt for the Texans as long as he punted for the Raiders. That would be quite a feat. Bill, speaking of favorites, DE Antonio Smith was a favorite in Houston. What has his role been Oakland?
Williamson: Smith is one of the many veterans the Raiders paid for this offseason. He is a starter and one of the leaders of Oakland’s defense. Week 1 wasn’t great for Smith and his defensive teammates, but the Raiders think he can help this season. Smith is a big fan of former teammate J.J. Watt. Who isn’t, right?
Ganguli: Watt’s play in the Texans' season opener was truly spectacular. He had a fumble recovery, a batted pass, a blocked extra-point attempt, two tackles for loss and a sack. Watt will be a problem for Oakland, no matter how they try to combat him. And what was really helpful for the Texans in their season opener was that Watt had help. That will be the challenge for Oakland. The Raiders can double Watt, as most teams do, but that creates opportunities for a guy like Brooks Reed, who had another outstanding game. Finally, Bill, how good is the Raiders’ run defense?
Williamson: The Raiders think they are going to have a stout run defense this season. They are big and strong up front. That didn’t help against the Jets, who had 212 yards rushing and averaged 6.2 yards per run. The difference in the game was a 71-yard touchdown run by New York’s Chris Ivory in the fourth quarter. The weather was warm and the defense was on the field a lot for Oakland. And they did wear down. That is an area this team must improve quickly.