Baseball Considers Division Mash-ups with Realignment


AP Photo/Charlie Riedel

Would Sluggerrr and his pals have a shot in the playoffs if they didn't have to see Minnesota, Detroit, Cleveland and the White Sox all the time?

Bud Selig is looking to tweak the Big Leagues again. "When I am on long airport rides I will fiddle around with divisions and things," he said at a recent spring training game. "The one thing about it: you come up with 100 different [scenarios]." Given that the game was between the Royals and Brewers, it's no wonder the commissioner was inspired to consider a few changes.

Four months ago, Selig appointed a 14-person special committee to come up with ways to improve the game. One idea that came out of the think-tank was the concept of "floating realignment. " Under that proposal, teams would no longer be permanently stuck in one division, but could switch from year to year based on factors such as payroll, location and whether they intended to make a run at the postseason.

Instead of trying to guess the commissioner's 100 scenarios, take a gander at some realignment proposals we'd like to see:


Every year we hear the same argument: large-market clubs make it impossible for smaller teams to compete, crushing the dreams of Orioles and Royals fans before June's over. Why not let the big spenders beat each other up and guarantee at least one of the minnows makes it to the dance? For example:

Billionaire Boys Division (Payroll of $115 million or more)

New York Yankees

New York Mets

Chicago Cubs

Boston Red Sox

Detroit Tigers

Penny Pinchers Division ($62 million or less)

Oakland Athletics

Washington Nationals

Pittsburgh Pirates

San Diego Padres

Florida Marlins

It's not going to stop the Yankees from winning another World Series, but at least you might catch a glimpse of the Pirates on the way up.


What Was Your Costume Designer Thinking Division

Boston Red Sox (Wally the Green Monster)

Cleveland Indians (Slider)

Tampa Bay Rays (Raymond)

Cincinnati Reds (Gapper)

Chicago White Sox (Southpaw)

Your Animal Has Nothing to Do with Your Team's Name Division

Seattle Mariners (Mariner Moose)

Colorado Rockies (Dinger)

Houston Astros (Junction Jack)

Minnesota Twins (T.C. Bear)

Arizona Diamondbacks (D. Baxter the Bobcat)


Frequent Flyer Division

San Diego Padres

Toronto Blue Jays

Seattle Mariners

Tampa Bay Rays

My Manager is More Explosive Than Your Manager Division

Philadelphia Phillies (Charlie Manuel)

Atlanta Braves (Bobby Cox)

Chicago White Sox (Ozzie Guillen)

Chicago Cubs (Lou Piniella)

Minnesota Twins (Ron Gardenhire)

All BBQ Division

Kansas City Royals

St. Louis Cardinals

Houston Astros

Atlanta Braves

(We don't suppose MLB could relocate a franchise to Memphis or the Carolinas, would they?)

What division would you like to see your team in?