It's official. I don't need surgery. After having my knee swell up like a balloon, and losing about 80 percent of my range of motion, it looked as if I was headed under the knife to repair a torn meniscus. But lo and behold, as is often the case in medicine, things were not quite as they seemed. An MRI revealed a partial tear of the popliteus tendon (a small but critical muscle on the back side of the knee that helps control rotation of the tibia and provides posterior lateral stability), a painful and unusual but nonsurgical condition. My lateral and my medial meniscus as well as my ACL are intact. Whew! Looks like my downtime is limited to avoiding running for a few weeks and being cautious with my knee. I have to be a good patient and wrap my leg, ice it and take my anti-inflammatories while I gradually work on regaining my strength and stability.
The good news? I will be able to make the All-Star festivities this year. Most importantly, I am reminded of the value of the outstanding health care professionals who spend countless years training just to "help people." I am reminded that the injuries that we regular folks suffer are often exactly the same as those that the athletes endure, which is perhaps why we identify so readily with them. And yes, I am reminded of how relieved all patients are when the news is less grim than originally thought. Now you want to know the status of the guys you really care about? Please, read on.
Magglio Ordonez, OF, Detroit Tigers: Ordonez strained an abdominal oblique muscle on his right side in the third inning of Saturday night's contest against the Rockies. Originally the team reported Ordonez's ailment as spasms on his right side, but the severity of the injury quickly became apparent when Ordonez was placed on the disabled list Sunday. The Detroit Free Press reported that Ordonez had difficulty moving when he woke up Sunday. When asked how he felt, Ordonez said it all with three simple words: "Not so good." The plan is for Ordonez to stay behind and rehabilitate while the team embarks on a seven-day road trip. The hope is that the 15-day DL will be enough to allow Ordonez to recover fully.
The oblique strain has been working its way through the Tigers' clubhouse like a virus, with Gary Sheffield and Brandon Inge out recently with similar injuries. Sheffield, who was recently reactivated, has been playing some of his best baseball this season since his return. On the flip side, Inge, who injured himself in early June, has been in and out of the lineup since, but never really healed. This week the Tigers decided to make the move to place him on the disabled list. Perhaps Inge's struggles in getting past pain while swinging the bat helped speed up the decision to rest Ordonez, whose power at the plate is far more valuable. The Tigers cannot afford to have him at less than full strength for weeks only to ultimately place him on the DL. His rehab activities by the second week should give a better clue as to how he is progressing.
Dan Uggla, 2B, Florida Marlins: Uggla sat out Sunday's game after spraining his left ankle Saturday. In the fourth inning Uggla was headed for second, trying to stretch a single into a double, but pulled up to go back to first and injured his ankle in the process. As Uggla limped along the baseline, he was tagged out and left the game. X-rays taken after the game were negative. Uggla later relayed that the dirt was wet, and when he stopped to turn back to first his plant foot just kept going forward and he couldn't catch himself in time. The Marlins' official Web site reported that Uggla was wearing a soft cast and sporting crutches after the game. For his part, Uggla says he didn't hear a pop and called this a mild sprain. He says he has injured this ankle before (at age 20) and described that episode as much worse.
The good news is that Uggla was able to put some weight on the ankle Sunday and managed to limp into the clubhouse on his own. He is officially listed as day-to-day but manager Fredi Gonzalez says the team will likely "stay away from him for a couple of days." The hope then is that he will be able to play during the upcoming road trip starting Thursday against the Rockies.
Hideki Matsui, DH, New York Yankees: Inflammation in the left knee continues to give Matsui trouble. He has now had the knee drained twice and has been placed on the 15-day DL effective Friday. If the problem doesn't subside, Matsui could be looking at a scope. According to The Associated Press, the Yankees insist that surgery is a last resort, but the fact is that it remains a possibility. The persistent inflammation is a sign that something is indeed irritating the joint. Abnormalities within the joint (such as cartilage damage or meniscus injury) can create irritation that results in the joint increasing fluid production. The fluid then blocks normal range of joint motion and can inhibit muscular contraction, both of which will render an athlete ineffective. And that doesn't even account for any pain that occurs as a result.
It would not be a surprise to see Matsui go under the knife, given his age (34) and history of intermittent problems with both knees. After all, Matsui had arthroscopic surgery on his right knee in the offseason and that seems to be holding up well. If the rest he gets in the next week or so does not result in significant improvement, do not be surprised if Matsui extends his time off so that he can undergo surgery.
Michael Cuddyer, OF, Twins: What's good for the goose is good for the gander, or so they say. Cuddyer, who suffered with an injury to his right (throwing) index finger earlier this year, now has an injury to his left index finger that is again forcing him onto the disabled list. In April, Cuddyer dislocated his right index finger and missed 20 days. This latest injury has been more gradual in nature. According to the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, Cuddyer has had pain in the left index finger for a couple of weeks, progressing to the point where he can hardly swing a bat. By Saturday, the pain was causing Cuddyer to lose his grip on the bat and he was even having pain at rest. The team is calling it a tendon strain and although they have not specified which tendon is involved, one would suspect a flexor tendon, on the palm side of the hand, because it is utilized when gripping, both while swinging the bat and fielding with the glove. The finger was clearly no better on Sunday since the team made the move to place Cuddyer on the DL. Depending on the degree of inflammation, Cuddyer may even need a little extra time beyond the two weeks. With the All-Star break approaching, consider him out until after that point, perhaps the following week.
Shaun Marcum, P, Toronto Blue Jays: When we last talked about Marcum he was on his way to visit with Dr. James Andrews and the worst was feared. Alas, it was not all doom and gloom for Marcum. Andrews confirmed the team's initial diagnosis of an elbow strain and cleared Marcum to initiate a throwing program Saturday, according to the Blue Jays' official Web site. Keep in mind, however, that the emphasis in a return to throwing program is gradual progression, and the Jays are wisely planning to be cautious with Marcum. Although eligible to return Friday, the Jays figure his absence will extend to after the All-Star break. With smart management, and a little luck, Marcum will fare well in the second half of the season.
Chipper Jones, 3B, Atlanta Braves: It seems Chipper Jones is a regular in the injury blog, but until now, despite the fact that he has had an injury for much of the season, Jones has not yet made a trip to the DL. Note the emphasis on "yet." The times may be a-changin' as Jones' quadriceps injury, despite his valiant efforts, may need the benefit of extended rest to really turn the corner. According to the Braves' official Web site, Jones can't run at greater than 50 percent effort because of pain. Although his bat has been hot, even as a pinch hitter he is at risk of further injury if he sprints. The last thing the Braves want is to lose him for the remainder of the season with a significant quadriceps tear. So far, Jones has managed to maintain a balance, contributing offensively and defensively on a regular basis while resting his leg a day or two at a time as needed. But the injury has progressively worsened each time Jones has aggravated it this year. For that reason, I believe Jones will ultimately end up on the disabled list and his quad will get some well-deserved rest, all of which should allow him to continue his amazing run in the second half of the season.
And in the good news department ...
Ryan Church, OF, New York Mets: Church was activated from the disabled list Sunday and went 2-for-4, picking up right where he left off. Church had not played since June 6 due to lingering effects of his second concussion this year. He was originally injured in a spring training collision with Marlon Anderson. Church suffered his second concussion in late May in Atlanta when he collided with Braves shortstop Yunel Escobar's knee while trying to break up a double play. Although he managed to pinch hit just two days later, Church did not start for 10 more days. His poor performance was explained by lingering symptoms that persisted after the second concussion. According to an ESPN report, Church was still experiencing dizziness, light sensitivity and discomfort on team flights and the decision was made to place Church on the DL. It appears to have been the right decision because Church looks like a new man. Now if only he can avoid another collision this season, he should be in good shape.
Eric Gagne, P, Milwaukee Brewers: Gagne was activated from the disabled list after missing time with rotator cuff tendinitis, but that doesn't mean he'll automatically be the closer. Salomon Torres has performed well in Gagne's absence and should continue in the role, leaving the set-up assignment for Gagne. The Brewers have to be happy, though, that they have options here. At least they have a chance to see if Gagne can regain his effectiveness before giving him the ball with the game on the line.