NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- The Titans' secondary was good last year, so defensive backs coach Brett Maxie should have been retained.
The Titans special teams were bad last year, so special teams coach Nate Kaczor and his assistant, Steve Hoffman, should not have been retained.
That's the popular thinking for at least a portion of Titans fans who are vocal on Twitter.
It's overly simplistic and incorrect.
I thought Maxie and assistant secondary coach Steve Brown did a good job last season.
Ken Whisenhunt kept Brown but let Maxie go.
Maybe he loved Maxie's work but has someone else in mind. Maybe he didn't like Maxie's work. Maybe a coaching colleague he trusts told him something about Maxie and something different about Brown. Maybe Ruston Webster gave him different reviews of the two. Maybe he's got a list of secondary coaches he covets and thinks a new guy working with a holdover will maximize the secondary's chances to do its best.
There are a number of factors that could have come into play. Whisenhunt's not going to spell them out for us.
The same is the case with regard to keeping Kaczor and Hoffman.
It's at least a partial endorsement of their work.
Tennessee's special teams were a problem last year, though things settled down when a quality returner, Leon Washington, fell into their lap late in the season.
But while those guys were heard, they weren't ultimately responsible for Darius Reynaud starting out as returner or Devon Wylie holding the job for a bit. Look higher up the Titans organizational chart for blame there -- to Mike Munchak and Webster.
As for silly, side-spinning, tee-less onside kicks ...
Perhaps Kaczor brought the idea to the table. But the head coach is the guy responsible for the team using it. Munchak, and any head coach, holds veto power and ultimate responsibility.
Whisenhunt is a smart coach who's respected around the league and arrives with six years as a head coach on his resume.
He's taken in some info and decided to keep the special teams assistants who were in place.
Rather than immediately call it a crazy move, how about we wait and see how they do given another chance?
There are good coaches who sometimes get bad results. There are bad coaches who sometimes get good results. Players are a huge variable, obviously.
The performance of the unit or position group is a factor -- Shawn Jefferson is back because he set the receivers on a good course.
It's not the only factor.
The list of assistants and their fates, per Jim Wyatt of The Tennessean:
Retained: Steve Watterson, assistant head coach/strength and conditioning; Steve Brown, assistant secondary coach; Sylvester Croom, running backs; Steve Hoffman, assistant special teams; Shawn Jefferson, wide receivers; Nate Kaczor, special teams.
TBA*: Jonathan Gannon, defensive assistant/quality control; Arthur Smith, offensive line/tight end assistant.
* Wyatt says they are retained for now, but the new offensive coordinator will have a say in what direction the team goes.