<
>

Defensive First and Second Team: No Marion? No Battier?

How the voters picked it:

FIRST TEAM
Bruce Bowen
Tim Duncan
Marcus Camby
Kobe Bryant
Raja Bell

SECOND TEAM
Ben Wallace
Jason Kidd
Tayshaun Prince
Kevin Garnett
Kirk Hinrich

How I would have picked it:

FIRST TEAM
Raja Bell
Shane Battier
Shawn Marion
Ben Wallace
Tim Duncan

SECOND TEAM
Bruce Bowen
Marcus Camby
Tayshaun Prince
Josh Howard
Rasheed Wallace

To quote Dave D'Alessandro of the Newark Star-Ledger: "Battier got screwed."

And here's a serious case for Shawn Marion as defensive player of the year.

UPDATE: I am something of a fool here, because I neglected to account for the reality that you have to vote for two forwards, two guards, and a center. So my teams, with about 700 forwards, are not exactly apples to apples. Carlos e-mailed: "Many of the suggested 'teams' championed by writers, bloggers, your neighbors, the mail carrier, bartenders, etc. would not fit the NBA rules. If you look at the actual vote counts as posted on NBA.com, you'll notice that Ben Wallace (second team) actually has more points than two members on the first team, but Camby narrowly edged him for the center position. So that drops Big Ben to the second team. I'm not saying that the All-Defensive teams shouldn't be just the 10 best defensive players, regardless of position, but those are the NBA's rules for choosing the teams. I like your recommended teams and they would absolutely be shut-down units, but it looks like you have one guard, seven forwards and two centers in your selections. The glut of talented forwards is a big reason why there were some notable omissions -- e.g. Marion and Battier."