In the lawsuit filed in Ninth Judicial Circuit Court, Erica Kinsman, the former FSU student who said Winston sexually assaulted her in his off-campus apartment, accused Winston of sexual battery, assault, false imprisonment and intentional infliction of emotional distress.
In the lawsuit, Kinsman's attorneys, David King of Orlando and Baine Kerr and John Clune of Boulder, Colorado, are demanding damages in excess of $15,000 and "the right to seek leave as to her entitlement to punitive damages." Her attorneys also demanded a jury trial.
According to the lawsuit, Winston's "conduct was extreme and outrageous and caused Plaintiff to suffer severe mental anguish and suffering, including, more specifically, loss of sleep, flashbacks, severe anxiety, fear of repeat sexual violence, an unfounded sense of shame and depression, all of which will continue to require psychological and other counseling."
"Erica hopes to show other survivors the strength and empowerment that can come from refusing to stay silent no matter what forces are against you," Clune said in a statement. "Jameis Winston in contrast has proven time and time again to be an entitled athlete who believes he can take what he wants. He took something here that he was not entitled to and he hurt someone. There are consequences for that behavior and since others have refused to hold him accountable, our client will."
Winston's attorney, David Cornwell, wasn't surprised by the civil lawsuit.
"This stunt was expected. Ms. Kinsman's false accusations have already been exposed and rejected six times. This time will be no different," Cornwell said. "Mr. Winston welcomes the opportunity to clear his name with the truth. ... He will not permit this ploy to distract him as he begins the journey of fulfilling his lifelong dream of being a championship quarterback in the National Football League."
Winston, the 2013 Heisman Trophy winner, was never criminally charged in the alleged incident. State attorney Willie Meggs declined to charge Winston after investigating the alleged incident in November 2013, and former Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Major Harding ruled in December that the evidence was insufficient to find Winston responsible for four violations of the university's student conduct code.
In the civil suit, Kinsman will be required to prove her case by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning a juror must believe her version of events more than Winston's. The burden of proof is lower than what is required in criminal court for a conviction, where the prosecution must prove the case "beyond a reasonable doubt."
According to the transcripts of the FSU disciplinary hearing, Winston and Kinsman provided starkly differing accounts of what occurred in December 2012. Winston says the sex was consensual. Kinsman, after being taken back to campus by Winston that night, went to a hospital, where a rape test was performed. Harding said in his judgment that he could not choose one version over the other.
"I do not find the credibility of one story substantially stronger than that of the other," Harding wrote. "Both have their own strengths and weaknesses."
Kinsman's attorneys also filed a federal lawsuit against the university in January. Kinsman alleged that she was subjected to a sexually hostile environment and that Florida State's "responses to the harassment were clearly unreasonable." In March, the school's board of trustees filed a motion to have the lawsuit dismissed.
Winston is expected to be among the first players chosen in this month's NFL draft. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers own the first overall pick.
Assistant State Attorney Georgia Cappleman on Friday told ESPN's Steve Delsohn that she spoke with a lawyer from the Buccaneers about Winston. Cappleman told Delsohn the conversation lasted approximately five minutes and was not very detailed. Cappleman said the Bucs' attorney did not ask anything about the investigation into Kinsman's sexual assault allegations against Winston, but did ask about another woman who also has said she had sex with Winston.
The New York Times in April 2014 reported that a victim advocate at Florida State, a month before Kinsman's accusations became public, learned of a woman who sought counseling after a sexual encounter with Winston. That woman did not accuse Winston of rape, but, as Cappleman told the Times, the advocate said the woman felt violated by the encounter and it "sheds some light on the way Mr. Winston operates."
Cappleman also told the newspaper that no crime had been committed. The second woman also was mentioned in the civil suit filed by Kinsman on Thursday. According to the suit, a victim advocate at Florida State on Oct. 25, 2013, told Kinsman "a second woman had come forward and reported being sexually assaulted by Winston."