But Friday, Alabama won.
"It was a real tough decision but I have decided to go to Alabama," said Black, who is No. 29 in the ESPNU 150 and the nation's No. 3 wide receiver. "I had some great choices and I really loved Alabama and Florida State. I kept praying about it and praying about it. In the end, Alabama is where my heart is and the school where I just feel more comfortable."
The problem was Black, 5-foot-11 and 175 pounds, also felt comfortable with the Seminoles. That made his decision much tougher.
"I have been going back and forth for a while between those two schools," he said. "In fact, if you would have asked me a month or so ago, it was probably going to be Florida State. I love both schools and just felt a little better with Alabama. There wasn't a major reason of Alabama over FSU. It was just a feel."
Another nod in Alabama's favor is recent history. The Crimson Tide won the BCS National Championship Game two years ago and are No. 2 in the USA Today top 25 coaches' poll, which was released Thursday.
Also, Alabama has produced NFL-ready players, and had four -- defensive tackle Marcell Dareus, wide receiver Julio Jones, running back Mark Ingram, and offensive guard James Carpenter -- taken in the first round of the draft in June.
"I believe I will have a better opportunity to play early at Alabama," Black said. "And I will get to play under coach (Nick) Saban. He and his staff have produced some great players and Julio Jones was just drafted very high in the NFL draft. Saban knows how to really develop guys and put them in the NFL."
Black is a big-play wide receiver with explosive speed who also will make a difference in the return game. But he brings more than just on-field talent to Tuscaloosa.
"He brings a lot to Alabama," said Frederick Culver, First Coast's defensive coordinator and assistant head coach. "The way Chris handled the whole entire recruiting situation speaks volumes about the great character of this young man. That's the kind of men Nick Saban wants at Alabama. He has handled things so well. As a player, Chris has incredible speed and great intangibles. The kid is a real playmaker and very durable. In four years of playing he has no injuries. This kid can get into the end zone and that's something Alabama needs."
This has been an intriguing week between Alabama and FSU. The Seminoles won a huge recruiting battle Wednesday, landing the nation's top quarterback, Hueytown (Ala.) High School's Jameis Winston.
But Friday, the Crimson Tide got even by landing Black.
"It's been a crazy week," said Black, who likely will play both outside receiver and in the slot in Alabama's offense. "I talked with Jameis a lot and we wanted to go to the same school. He's going to be a great quarterback for FSU. It just didn't work out for us to play together."
With Black, Alabama has 15 commitments, including six players in the ESPNU 150.
"I know I will have a lot of prove when I get to Alabama," Black said. "But I am a runner that's quick and has great feet. I can be their deep threat. I can play on the inside or out. I can play on special teams. I can do a lot for Alabama. I will do whatever they ask."
Jamie Newberg has been covering recruiting both in the Southeast and nationally for 19 years. He can be reached at email@example.com.