Does Denard Robinson ever have an off game ... or just a so-so game, for that matter? The answer, of course, is no. The star of Michigan football (and college football) continued to make it look easy this week. Robinson torched Indiana for five touchdowns and 494 yards of total offense Saturday, and became the first player in college football history to pass and rush for 200 yards in a regular-season game twice. Not to mention he did it all with his shoelaces untied.
So really, D-Rob at No. 1 was the only choice. It was the other nine spots that had our panel debating up a storm. Is Donovan McNabb too high? Is Tom Brady too low? Now is your chance to let us know below!