Alex Rodriguez

TBD By Editor
Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

Alex Rodriguez, SS/3B


Career: 1994-, Mariners, Rangers, Yankees
Fun fact: Only SS with a 50-homer season

The numbers: 654 home runs (fifth), 1,969 RBIs (sixth), 1,919 runs scored (10th), 115.7 WAR (12th among position players).

His story isn't so simple as the numbers, so I'll choose to remember 1996, when he was a 20-year-old hitting .358 and spraying doubles and home runs all over the Kingdome and he had the potential to be one of the best there ever was. He got there, but at what price? -- David Schoenfield

Previous rank: 19