Don Sutton, RHP
Career: 1966-88, Dodgers, Astros, Brewers, Angels, Athletics
Fun fact: Most PA without a homer (1,559)
It might seem hard to call a man with 324 career wins unlucky, but Sutton never led his league in wins. He had seven 9-inning no-decisions despite not allowing a run.
What Sutton did have going for him was durability, which is why he racked up big career totals. He ranks seventh all time with 3,574 strikeouts, yet he never won a strikeout title.