Bobby Jones
Starting Pitcher, New York Mets
2000 NLDS, Game 4

It was the best game of his life, as Jones -- who posted a 5.06 ERA during the season -- pitched a one-hit shutout to push the Mets past the Giants. The only hit he allowed was a leadoff double to Jeff Kent in the fifth inning. And among his five strikeouts were two against Barry Bonds.

SportsNation: Vote on the best playoff performances

Doug Kanter/AFP/Getty Images