A day after the Indians routed the Yankees 12-3 in their playoff opener Thursday night, the buzz around town wasn't about Cleveland's offensive power surge or pitcher C.C. Sabathia's gutty performance.
Instead, fans jammed sports talk radio lines and Internet message boards, crying foul over their frustration with the NBA superstar's traitorous appearance in the stands wearing a Yankees cap.
"The guy is the face of Cleveland sports and he's not even rooting for a team that's 100 feet from the building he plays in," said Adam Burke, who was waiting outside the left-field gate for Game 2 on Friday.
James' office, Quicken Loans Arena, sits just across a plaza from Jacobs Field. The Eastern Conference champions are displaying a large banner on the building wishing the Indians good luck in the postseason.
But their All-Star forward, who grew up in nearby Akron, isn't backing one of his hometown clubs. The 22-year-old, who also roots for the Dallas Cowboys, has worn his Yankees cap around town for years and last week while in New York rehearsing for "Saturday Night Live" predicted the Yankees would beat the Indians.
Fans have mostly tolerated James' decision to back the hated Yankees, who have been the Indians' foil since the 1950s.
But last night's appearance behind home plate wearing the dreaded interlocking NY insignia, may have been too much to bear. James not only wore the cap but also flaunted it, at one point holding it high over his head.
Later, though, as the Indians began to pull away, he put it on backward and left the ballpark holding it in his hands. One fan even offered his Indians cap to James, who slapped hands with others as he exited.
Around town, James' actions caused an uproar.
"LeBron James. King of Nothing. Fan of Yankees. Get Out of Town," read a sign Friday at a Marathon gas station in suburban North Ridgeville.
"From a PR standpoint, that's a terrible decision," said Burke, 20, who doesn't like that James has distracted from the Indians' win. "That's the sad thing. We dominate every aspect of the game but LeBron's dominating the airwaves. Maybe he wants it that way."
A few blocks away from Jacobs Field, fans were still getting their pictures taken in front of the Nike "Witness" billboard on the side of a downtown office building.
"So what if he wears a Yankees hat?" said Willie Watson of Cleveland. "He wins games for Cleveland.
"So he likes the Yankees. Boo hoo. Big deal," Watson said. "What's next? We don't like him because he listens to hip-hop instead of the Cleveland Orchestra?"
Sabathia, who is friends with James, has backed his buddy's right to show Yankee pride.
"I don't think it's that big a deal," Sabathia said again Friday. "I knew he was coming, but I didn't know he had a Yankees hat on and stuff. My family told me people were all over him."
James has been in the spotlight since his sophomore year in high school. His immense talent has been matched by a maturity beyond his years. He has always spoken with diplomacy and grace in the media spotlight.
This was a rare misstep for James, whose every move on and off the floor has been scrutinized.
Sabathia, who grew up in Vallejo, Calif., and is an Oakland Raiders fan, said he wouldn't hesitate to show up at a Browns game in a silver and black jersey.
"If they played the Raiders in a championship game, definitely I would," said the Game 1 starter, one of several Indians players who attend Cavaliers games to cheer on James.
Hall of Famer Reggie Jackson, who was a national icon on the level of James 30 years ago, thought for a moment when asked if he would have done something similar.
"If I was in Oakland and they were playing the San Francisco Giants, would I have worn, say, a Willie Mays jersey?" said Jackson, who began his career with the Athletics. "Yes, I'd have to say so.
"That's because I could say 'Willie Mays' before I could say the word 'baseball' growing up. He was my hero," Jackson said.
The Yankees didn't see anything wrong with what James did, either.
"He's a Yankee fan. Why would that rub us the wrong way?" Yankees superstar Derek Jeter said grinning.