It all unfolded in frustrating fashion in the sixth.
Verlander stumbled again, Cabrera left after straining his right groin and Detroit wasted a three-run lead against the Minnesota Twins, who burst ahead when Eddie Rosario hit a three-run homer that capped a six-run sixth inning in a 6-3 victory.
Cabrera, a two-time AL MVP, had three hits but was hurt in the sixth when he dove for a ground ball by Robbie Grossman that got past Cabrera and second baseman Ian Kinsler to score two runs. Cabrera felt it again when he stretched for a throw from third baseman Nicholas Castellanos on Brian Dozier's inning-ending grounder.
Cabrera was replaced at first base by Alex Avila to start the seventh and the team announced he would be re-evaluated Saturday.
"When he got back into the dugout after the inning, he let the trainers know and we just removed him from the game," Tigers manager Brad Ausmus said.
Six days after allowing nine runs and 11 hits in four innings against Cleveland, Verlander (1-2) held the Twins to two hits in five innings and led 3-0 before walking Max Kepler, Miguel Sano and Joe Mauer starting the sixth.
"I know I faced him the first time actually in Detroit, I remember the fastball goes up," Rosario said of Jimenez. "But I waited for this pitch and he threw me first pitch."
Verlander, whose ERA rose to 6.04, allowed four runs, three hits and six walks -- one shy of his career high -- in five-plus innings. He had been 12-1 in his previous 18 starts against the Twins.
"Inexcusable there," Verlander said. "I just lost my tempo and rhythm. That many walks, with us up like that, that can't happen."
Hector Santiago (2-1) gave up three runs and seven hits in 6 1/3 innings, and Ryan Pressly, Taylor Rogers and Brandon Kintzler combined for one-hit relief. Kintzler got his fourth save in as many chances.
Both teams were coming off being swept in their last series.
"It was just a good win," Twins manager Paul Molitor said. "We kind of feel like you need one after kind of stumbling through the last series."
Rosario, Santiago and Jimenez all played together for Puerto Rico in the WBC and the team has kept a chat going since the tournament. Santiago said Jimenez would hear about giving Rosario a first-pitch fastball.
"I think that young factor comes into play there, where you got a guy up there that loves fastballs," Santiago said of the rookie Jimenez. "You got to understand that. He'll learn.
"We'll say thank you to him tonight in our group chat and we'll say, `Appreciate you giving it.' We're definitely going to talk about that tonight, for sure. But thanks Joe and attaboy Rosie."
Tigers: SS Jose Iglesias was placed on the seven-day concussion DL, retroactive to Thursday. Iglesias took a knee to his jaw on the final play of Wednesday's game.
Twins: INF Ehire Adrianza (right oblique strain) went 3 for 5 in his first rehab start for Class A Fort Myers on Friday, starting at shortstop.
Rookie LHP Adalberto Mejia (0-1, 4.05 ERA) is to start for Minnesota on Saturday and LHP Matt Boyd (2-1, 3.77) for Detroit. Mejia's rotation spot was skipped when Minnesota's game on Wednesday was rained out. Boyd beat the Twins on April 11 with six scoreless innings.
More AP baseball coverage: https://apnews.com/tag/MLBbaseball
A beanball war between the Miami Marlins and San Francisco Giants has the potential to spill over into Wednesday's series finale, with neither manager saying the book was closed after there were three hit batsmen and two ejections Tuesday night.
Rookie left-hander Joey Lucchesi will be activated from the San Diego Padres' 10-day disabled list Wednesday morning to face the Oakland A's in the finale of an abbreviated, two-game homestand at Petco Park.
When he starts Wednesday against the New York Mets, Chad Bettis will try to build off his last game for the Colorado Rockies, one that included a deceptively bad pitching line that masked an abrupt turnaround.
Priorities? The Giants literally hurt themselves and risked hurting other players by going after a rookie hitting .180.
Stephen Piscotty homered with two outs in the ninth inning to tie the game and Jed Lowie hit a two-run shot with two outs in the 10th to lift the Oakland Athletics over the San Diego Padres 4-2 on Tuesday night.
Mike Trout drove in two runs, Kole Calhoun and Ian Kinsler added solo homers and the Los Angeles Angels held on for a 5-4 victory over the Arizona Diamondbacks on Tuesday night.