The Tigers star wasn't in the lineup due to biceps tightness, but Cash was unsure if Cabrera could make an appearance with the game on the line.
"I saw him in the dugout with a bat, and I started asking everyone I could find if he could swing," Cash said. "I even asked the batboy at one point. I didn't want to see him step onto the field."
Luckily for Cash, Cabrera was bluffing and the Rays were able to close out a 3-2 win.
"That's a great win after a tough loss yesterday," Cash said.
Tampa Bay has won nine of its last 10 games after a 4-13 start.
With the game scoreless, Detroit closer Shane Greene (1-2) walked Denard Span to start the ninth. C.J. Cron followed by hitting a 2-0 fastball into the right-center field seats for his seventh homer of the season.
"I'm not sure what happened there -- I need to watch the video," Greene said. "I have to figure it out and get things fixed."
"Our closer came in and just didn't get it done," Tigers manager Ron Gardenhire said. "His ball didn't have the life that it normally does and two very strong hitters got him. It happens."
Cash, though, didn't have closer Alex Colome available for the ninth inning.
"He's had four hot days in a row, so he was down for the night," he said. "At that point, we are just trying to piece together three outs."
Chaz Roe, who has never recorded a save in six major-league seasons, started the inning, but loaded the bases with one out on two hit batters and an infield single.
Jose Alvarado allowed a two-run single to Victor Martinez, then retired James McCann before walking John Hicks to load the bases again. Dixon Machado then grounded into a game-ending force at second to give Alvarado his first career save.
"They told me to trust Jesus (Sucre) to call the pitches and to do what I do," Alvarado said. "The crowd was fired up and my adrenaline was pumping, but I didn't want to change a thing."
Rays starter Jake Faria (2-1) had the longest outing of his career, holding the Tigers scoreless for eight innings. He gave up three hits and a walk with six strikeouts in his second win in 11 starts.
"I was in the bullpen by the end of the game yesterday, just in case, so I knew we needed some innings," Faria said. "I tried to pitch to contact and get groundballs, which isn't my normal game, but my fastball and slider were both really good."
Tigers starter Jordan Zimmermann didn't get a decision after pitching seven scoreless innings. He allowed two hits, walked one and struck out five.
"It was fun to be out there," he said. "I had all four pitches working and I was able to throw some good changeups when I needed them. We didn't win, which is unfortunate, but it was definitely something I needed."
Jose Iglesias helped Zimmermann with two outstanding plays in the third inning. He made a leaping catch of Sucre's soft liner, then dived to his right to grab Cron's line drive.
Iglesias doubled with one out in the bottom of the inning, but was stranded at third.
The Rays got a runner to third with two outs in the seventh, but Zimmerman got Joey Wendle to ground out to Iglesias.
Rays: C Wilson Ramos sat out a second straight game with tightness in both legs. He has homered in his last three games. ... Sucre injured his right arm blocking a ninth-inning pitch. He stayed in the game after treatment, and post-game X-rays were negative.
Tigers: CF Leonys Martin was out of the lineup with a sore hamstring but pinch ran in the ninth inning. ... Cabrera is listed as day-to-day. ... LHP Daniel Norris, who is scheduled to undergo groin surgery, was placed on the 60-day disabled list. The Tigers recalled LHP Chad Bell from Triple-A Toledo.
The teams play again Tuesday night in the second of a three-game series. LHP Matthew Boyd (0-2, 2.74) is scheduled to pitch for the Tigers, while RHP Chris Archer (2-1, 6.61) will start for Tampa Bay. Archer will be making his ninth career start against Detroit, having gone 2-2 with a 3.55 ERA.
NL East Stock Watch: Which team is having the best winter?
The division's four contenders have made the biggest moves to restock their rosters, but they're far from finished.
Schefter: Murray will go in 1st round
Adam Schefter joins SportsCenter to analyze Kyler Murray's decision to declare for the NFL draft.
Kyler Murray declares for 2019 NFL draft: Answering questions about what's next
Murray has declared for the NFL draft. Can he still play baseball? What are the key dates to pay attention to? Here's what you need to know.
Deion: Murray has to be fully invested in football
Deion Sanders breaks down why Kyler Murray can't be a multi-sport athlete like himself and Bo Jackson.
Derek Holland re-signs with Giants on one-year deal
Derek Holland, who made 30 starts with the Giants last season, re-signed with San Francisco on a one-year deal, the team announced.
How Bryce Harper and Manny Machado measure up among baseball's best
This winter's free-agent duo will be very rich pretty soon, but where do Harper and Machado rank among the best players in baseball right now?