Instead, he got an easy bases-loaded walk to cap an unexpected comeback.
The Indians led 4-0 and 8-4 before Detroit's breakthrough seventh for its third straight win. Miller (1-2) allowed two inherited runners to score, then allowed two runs of his own. He faced six batters, giving up two doubles and three walks while getting one out.
After Dan Otero gave up a run and left two on for Miller in the seventh, Jones and Pete Kozma hit back-to-back RBI doubles before walks by Victor Martinez and Niko Goodrum loaded the bases with two outs. Miller then walked John Hicks to force in the go-ahead run.
"I was looking for a good pitch to hit, but he wasn't even coming close," Hicks said. "He threw a strike on 3-0, when I was taking all the way, but nothing else was near the strike zone."
Miller wasn't sure what went wrong.
"I wasn't going to let Victor hurt me, and I had to tip my cap to Goodrum for a great at-bat," Miller said. "Hicks, though, was just horrible. There is no excuse for that."
Tigers manager Ron Gardenhire planned to stick with Stumpf regardless -- he didn't have a choice, since he was out of usable relief pitchers. He did try to bluff Indians manager Terry Francona, though.
"We told Buck (Farmer) to stand there but not throw a pitch," Gardenhire said. "But Stumpf was a live arm and we needed him to get himself out of the mess he had created."
Gardenhire ended up using Greene in the ninth despite wanting to rest him.
Guyer hit a first-pitch fastball into the Tigers bullpen for his first career grand slam in the first inning off starter Francisco Liriano.
Liriano left with runners on the corners and one out in the fifth, and Zac Reininger got Guyer to hit into a double play.
Hicks pulled the Tigers within 5-2 with an RBI single in the fifth, and Jose Iglesias' run-scoring groundout made it a two-run game.
Davis, though, hit a two-run double off Reininger in the sixth to give Cleveland a 7-3 lead, and he scored on Ramirez's double off Hicks' glove at first.
Castellanos homered in the sixth to make it 8-4 and end Tomlin's night.
Indians: Cleveland placed CF Bradley Zimmer (rib) on the 10-day disabled list, retroactive to May 12, and selected the contract of RHP Neil Ramirez from Triple-A Columbus. To make room for Ramirez on the 40-man roster, LHP Ryan Merritt (knee) was moved to the 60-day disabled list.
UP NEXT: The teams finish a three-game series Wednesday afternoon with Cleveland's Trevor Bauer (2-3, 3.00) facing a Tigers pitcher to be named. Detroit will need to use a spot starter because of Saturday's doubleheader and Jordan Zimmermann's shoulder injury.
More AP baseball: https://apnews.com/tag/MLBbaseball
Could these 'mystery teams' be in on Manny Machado, Bryce Harper?
Are the Yankees set to swoop in on Manny after all? Who might be biding their time for Bryce? We look at some of the potential surprise suitors insiders are talking about.
'I came up on one-year deals': How Joe Maddon is approaching 2019
As the skipper enters his potential final year in Chicago, Maddon is leaving no stone unturned as he tries to get the Cubs back on track after a disappointing finish and a quiet offseason.
Will Bryce Harper and Manny Machado sign before Super Bowl Sunday and other burning questions
With the offseason providing few answers for baseball's superstar free agents, we shed some light on where things stand and where they're headed.
Red Sox unlikely to spend big to sign closer, Dave Dombrowski says
Red Sox president Dave Dombrowski said Thursday he doesn't expect to spend a lot of money on a closer.
Cubs GM: Giving second chance to Addison Russell 'was the right thing to do'
Cubs owner Tom Ricketts said the team decided it would rather support Addison Russell after his suspension for violating the league's domestic abuse policy rather than "just cut him."
Yankees, Adam Ottavino agree to 3-year, $27 million deal
Free-agent reliever Adam Ottavino, who had a breakout 2018 season as the setup man for closer Wade Davis with the Rockies, has agreed to sign with the Yankees, sources told ESPN.