Originally Published: February 10, 2014

Daily Word: Marcus Smart's punishment

By ESPN.com


Every weekday, Andy Katz leads a panel of our college hoops experts in a discussion of the biggest issues, trends and themes happening in and around college basketball.

1. Was Marcus Smart's suspension the appropriate length?

Andy Katz: Yes. Three games is a significant hit for him and the team. But if Oklahoma State wanted to put even more teeth in the punishment, they could have prevented him from practicing too. His apology was sincere, but he still needs to answer why he allegedly told a radio staffer that he heard a racial slur.

Dana O'Neil: Yes. It needed to have some substance to send the proper message that his behavior was not tolerable but also allow Smart a chance to rebuild himself and his reputation before the season is out.

Myron Medcalf: I think the punishment fits the crime. But a lengthier suspension wouldn't have been an injustice. Jeff Orr crossed the line by shouting at a 19-year-old, but there's no room in this game for Smart's response.

2. How will Oklahoma State fair over the next three games without Smart?

Katz: The Cowboys will likely lose at Texas. The Oklahoma game in Stillwater then becomes a massive game for the Pokes. OSU needs to get that one before a road game at Baylor. I will say a 1-2 stretch.

O'Neil: It's hard to imagine things will go well for the Cowboys without Smart since they haven't been going terribly well with him. Sometimes teams rally around adversity and find a new purpose in a season going terribly awry. But with three tough opponents, including two on the road, that's a tall order for Oklahoma State.

Medcalf: Well, the Pokes weren't too hot with him. They had just lost to Texas Tech when Smart was available, so more stumbles seem likely, especially since they're at Texas, versus Oklahoma and at Baylor during this three-game stretch. This team's NCAA tournament hopes become slimmer by the day.

3. What do you expect from Smart when he returns?

Katz: Smart will come back more focused. He will still be intense but will be more selective with his shot. He needs to reshape his image, and this is his chance to lead OSU back into the NCAA tournament. He needs to do this for NBA personnel decision-makers too.

O'Neil: That will be interesting. Hopefully, he will find a way to still play with passion and fire but temper his emotions and channel them properly. Smart can't afford to play like a zombie because he's fearful that everyone will be watching his every move. Yet at the same time, he has to be conscious of where the line is and not dare to even come close to it.

Medcalf: I think Smart will learn from this and change his ways. I think he'll be focused on basketball. But he's such a gamer that he might try to carry too much of the load when he comes back. He returned for his sophomore season, in part, because he wanted to lead his team to the Final Four. They're so far from that dream that Smart might feel like he has to do everything once he's back, which wouldn't be good for Oklahoma State.

Earlier Words: 2/7 » 2/6 » 2/5 » 2/4 » 2/3 » 1/31 » 1/30 » 1/29 » 1/28 » 1/27 »


Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, photo & other personal information you make public on Facebook will appear with your comment, and may be used on ESPN's media platforms. Learn more.