PROVO, Utah -- An 18-year-old woman identified former Brigham Young University football player B.J. Mathis as one of the men who sexually assaulted her at a Provo apartment a year ago in court testimony Thursday.
The teenager from suburban Salt Lake City was the first witness in the trial of Mathis and Ibrahim Rashada, both 19, who are accused of raping the then-17-year-old in August 2004. They are charged with aggravated sexual assault, dealing harmful material to a minor, furnishing alcohol to a minor and obstructing justice.
The woman said she was attacked by three, possibly four, men after she passed out from drinking vodka and went to a bedroom to lie down.
"I blacked out, fell asleep and the very next thing I remember was the sound of voices and laughter," she said, sobbing on the witness stand in 4th District Court. "It sounded like I was under water."
She said she doesn't know how long she was unconscious. When she
came to, she said there were two men, one forcing her into oral sex
and another into intercourse. She identified one of her attackers
"They kept saying, 'Shhh, you're fine, you're fine. Just be
quiet,' " she testified.
She said Rashada was in the apartment, but on direct questioning
from the defense she said she could not remember Rashada being in
the bedroom -- although she identified him to police as one of her
In opening statements earlier in the day, prosecutor Dave Sturgill told jurors that the girl voluntarily went with a group of football players to one of their apartments. He contended the
players got her drunk, then raped her after she had blacked out.
Two other players were charged with rape. One has taken a plea
agreement, and the case of the other is in juvenile court.
Additionally, two others were charged with lesser crimes in the
case. All the players were either suspended or expelled for failure
to comply with the school's strict honor code. None is still with
The combined trial for Rashada and Mathis is expected to take up
to a week. The girl was the state's first witness. Her cousin, who
was with her at the apartment but left, also took the stand
Defense attorneys contended that the girl's story will not hold
up. They questioned how much the girl had to drink, and whether it
was enough to make her black out, as she claimed.
One defense attorney said the girl was at the apartment
voluntarily and although the allegations are distasteful, the sex
"What happened at that particular place in that particular time
was not illegal," said Dean Zabriskie, who is representing
Jere Reneer, who is representing Mathis, told jurors during his
opening statements that the girl didn't go to police until more
than 12 hours after the alleged rape, and only did so after her
ex-boyfriend said there would no be chance of reconciling their
relationship unless she pressed charges.
"It's a 'she said' versus the entire ream of evidence," Reneer
Mathis and Rashada, who are both black, sat quietly to the left
of the all-white jury. The eight-member panel with one alternate
includes seven men and two women.
The defendants' family members sat in the courtroom and nodded
in agreement when the defense questioned why the girl didn't leave
the apartment immediately if she felt uncomfortable, as she later
told police she was.
Family members of the girl murmured as the defense questioned
her story during the opening statements.
Another former player, Karland Bennett, has pleaded guilty to
dealing harmful material to a minor and obstructing justice, and
his sentencing is scheduled for October. Two counts of aggravated
sexual assault were dropped. Another former player's case was moved
to juvenile court because he was 17 at the time of the alleged
Two others were charged with lesser offenses and will have their
misdemeanor charges dropped from their records if they abide by
conditions set by the court. Antwaun Harris, 19, entered a plea to
a misdemeanor charge of making false statements to a police
officer, and Billy Skinner, 19, pleaded no contest to a misdemeanor
charge of attempted dealing harmful material to a minor.