ESPN

50 Greatest Yankees Photo Gallery

Grid
41 of 51
Previous
Next

11. Don Mattingly

Photograph By USA TODAY Sports

Besides two active shoo-ins, Donnie Baseball is the highest-ranking non-Hall of Famer on our list. Before a bad back sidetracked him, the ex-captain was the game's best player in the mid-'80s, winning nine Gold Gloves at first base and the 1985 MVP award.