Butler's benching wasn't disciplinary, according to Belichick after the Super Bowl, but nonetheless sparked rumors that Butler addressed on social media. That was something McCourty felt was disappointing.
"I get why people are fishing. The guy played 98 percent of the plays [in the regular season]. I just hate that for him character-wise going into free agency; it's just not true. As far as I know, and I was there all week, not one time did anything come up," McCourty said on Saturday at a Rutgers-based fundraiser for his charity Tackle Sickle Cell.
Despite McCourty's contention, one Patriots defensive starter reiterated to ESPN's Josina Anderson on Monday that he "definitely didn't know" that Butler wasn't going to play in the Super Bowl. The starter and one teammate previously told Anderson on Feb. 5 that they weren't made aware of the Patriots' plan for Butler.
Patriots DT Alan Branch said "I didn't know anything, honestly," when asked Tuesday on WEEI's "Dale and Holley Show with Rich Keefe" if he knew prior to the game that Butler wouldn't play. "On our team, gossip doesn't travel, let's just say that."
""I noticed he wasn't in the game," Branch said, "but then again, you never know the reason for what's going on at a certain time in that organization, especially."
Butler's replacement in the starting lineup, Eric Rowe, had said after the Super Bowl that he didn't know he would be starting until close to kickoff. But Rowe also said at the time that it wasn't a surprise to him that he played 72 of 75 defensive snaps in the Super Bowl.
As for Butler's lack of action, Rowe said at the Super Bowl that he was surprised Butler didn't play in the game. "That wasn't the plan," he said.
The Patriots' defense struggled in the Super Bowl, particularly in their dime package (six defensive backs). The team initially played two cornerbacks and four safeties in the dime before making a halftime adjustment and playing with three corners and three safeties, but still without Butler.
Butler had been on the injury report in the week leading up to the Super Bowl with an illness, and he had been limited in one practice leading up to the game. He had arrived one day after the team to Super Bowl LII, with the team citing the illness as the reason.