Jason Parkhurst/US Presswire

Eli Manning

New York Giants | Super Bowl XLII

Against all odds, Eli Manning kept his cool. On a stage that registered a record-setting TV audience, the unbeaten New England Patriots were favored to win by 12½ points over the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLII. With time dwindling down, Manning marched the Giants down the field with an 83-yard game-winning touchdown drive. Along with taking home the MVP, Manning stepped out of his brother's shadow and became only the second quarterback to throw two go-ahead fourth-quarter touchdowns in a Super Bowl.