ESPN Network: | | ABCSports | EXPN | FANTASY

Readers' List: Greatest baseball season ever
From the Page 2 mailbag

Poll Results

Email story
Most sent
Print story

On Monday, researcher Rico Longoria helped Page 2 list the greatest seasons in baseball history. We asked for your take, and you filled our mailbag with plenty of choices.

Here's how researcher Rico Longoria ranked the greatest single-season records by individuals in sports history:

1. 1991
2. 1998
3. 1941
4. 1908
5. 1986
6. 1951
7. 1967
8. 1968
9. 1924
10. 1985

After going through more than 600 e-mails, we've listed Page 2 readers' top 10 choices below. Be sure to vote in the poll at left to crown the greatest baseball season in history.

1. 1998 (138 letters)
Without a doubt 1998, I believe it was the season that brought back America's pastime after the strike.

The reasons: We saw Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa not only break but shatter the home run record, The Ironman ended his streak at 2,632, Wells threw a perfecto and the Yanks went on to win the World Series after setting the AL record for regular season wins at 114. The only season that may beat that is the current season!
Benny Rodriguez

McGwire and Sosa with the HRs, Ripken sits down, Wood Ks 20, Wells throws a perfect game, the NL wild-card came down to the last day with three teams separated by a game and then the Cubs-Giants playoff game.
Marc M.
Hoboken, N.J.

Mark McGwire
Mark McGwire helped make 1998 the year of the long ball.
Sosa and McGwire ... I can recall a Sunday afternoon watching the Cards play the Cubs in early September just as they were both about to break the record. My mom and sisters joined me in watching the game. They've never watched any sporting event with me -- especially a "boring" baseball game.
Matt Hendrickson
Fort Wayne, Ind.

2. 1991 (59 letters)
Minnesota Twins won the World Series. That automatically makes it a great season, but the fact that they, along with the Atlanta Braves, went from worst-to-first makes it even more memorable. Plus with Nolan Ryan's no-hitter, Dennis Martinez's perfect game, and Rickey Henderson breaking the stolen base record (which will never be broken), and the best Series ever, 1991 was the best season of them all.
Cedar Rapids, Iowa

You're right. It's gotta be the 1991 season. Rickey got the steals record, but the best part of the whole season was the last 36 hours of it. Puckett's amazing Game 6 heroics got him into the Hall of Fame, the greatest quote in Minnesota sports history, and one of the best of all time in any sport's history ("... and we'll see you tomorrow night!") and then Jack Morris' amazing 10-inning defiance of the Braves was truly the way to end the greatest season and the greatest World Series in the history of the game.
Clint Rusch
Madison, Wis.

The last great season before big money and television really started to move in on baseball was 1991.

The Braves and the Pirates hooked up in a crazy finish and then the Twins and Braves met in one of the best World Series ever. Goes to prove that we need a salary cap in baseball more than anything, the divisions were so tight and close, that by the end of the season, anything could have happened. A great year with great stars, many of them in their twilight years, the next few years seemingly became a changing of the guards as today's stars started to come into their own. Where it all started -- 1991.
Ben Stanton

3. 1986 (56 letters)
My vote is for 1986. The regular season was outstanding, and the postseason was unforgettable with Dave Henderson's home run in the ALCS (which, unfortunately haunted Donnie Moore until his untimely death) and, of course, Bill Buckner's error.

I will remember 1986 most though for the rookies. That year can be credited with the rookie baseball craze. Look at the lineup -- Wally Joyner, Jose Canseco, Will Clark, and guys named Bonds and McGwire who got a cup of coffee.

For no other reason, 1986 had the finest postseason in baseball history. All three series produced such excruciating drama.To this day, I still insist that the greatest baseball game I ever watched was Game 5 of the '86 ALCS. The Game 6s of the World Series and of the NLCS would also fall into my top five.
Lance Milner
Chandler, Ariz.

4. 2001 (43 letters)
Barry Bonds
We might not have yet seen the best of Barry Bonds and 2001.
Although the season hasn't finished yet, I'd say the greatest season ever is 2001.

This season had it all: the chase of 70 by Barry Bonds, the farewell tours of Cal Ripken Jr. and Tony Gwynn, and the inspiring comeback of the New York Mets. Although there aren't any pennant races in the AL, you have the possible record-breaking season of the Seattle Mariners, the second-half resurgence of the Oakland A's, and the expected dominance by the Yankees and Indians.

In the National League, the pennant races exist in each division and also includes a tight wild-card race.

You also have superb seasons by Sammy Sosa, Luis Gonzalez, Alex Rodriguez, and Ichiro Suzuki who personally introduced the United States to Japanese baseball. So, for all these reasons, 2001 was a spectacular season.
Andrew Tarkowski
Syracuse, N.Y.

5. 1969 (33 letters)
The Miracle Mets. Willie Mays hits his 600th home run, joining Babe Ruth in the club. Sparky Anderson is hired by the Reds (hello, Big Red Machine!). Babe Ruth named greatest all-time player ... Joe DiMaggio named Greatest Living Player. And last but not least ... for all the Red Sox fans. Dick Williams pulls Carl Yastrzemski from the Boston lineup and fines him $500 for "dogging it."
Shonn Stanley

6. 1961 (25 letters)
How could you overlook an amazing year? The home run chase between Roger and Mickey alone would get my vote. Forget that Whitey Ford went 25-4 and Ralph Terry went 16-3.

In addition to Roberto Clemente's best all around year (.351 23 89) adding more than 200 hits and 10 triples! Hitting for power and average, combined with speed and an tremendous heart for the game. Former Hall of Famer and Cub great Billy Williams first full year. Not to mention, Carl Yastrzemski's rookie year with the Red Sox. The Yankees posting 109 wins, the most in baseball since 1927, going on to win the Series.
Michael Collins
Syracuse, N.Y.

7. 1941 (14 letters)
Ted Williams
Ted Williams' .406 batting average is one of many reasons that made 1941 great.
The choice has to be the 1941 season. As our nation was on the verge of a horrible war (one that would claim some of these players' prime seasons), baseball entered its modern era.

Just as the Ruth era was falling away, Joe DiMaggio and Ted Williams were good, but until this year they never had that gigantic quality about them. Their performances sent America into the second great baseball renaissance, one that would last until a greedy corrupt sport emerged with the strike in '96.
Brandon Carter
Abilene, Texas

8. 1995 (12 letters)
Coming off the strike you had the Mariners comeback over the Angels, the Indians and Albert Belle dominate until the World Series, and of course the Cal Ripken streak. A lot of people came back to loving baseball even after the strike because of this season. Without this season and these stories we would not have watched the ones after.
Washington D.C.

9. 1947 (10 letters)
Jackie Robinson
Jackie Robinson's impact alone made 1947 great and important.
It is simply the greatest, as well as the most important, season in baseball history. It, of course, is the season that Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier, and thus, entered baseball into a new era.

Also, 1947 was a year when "Spahn and Sain and pray for rain" each won more than 20 games for the Boston Braves, Johnny Mize and Ralph Kiner both hit more than 50 homers, Ted Williams won the AL Triple Crown (but still lost the AL MVP by a single point to Joe DiMaggio, as Williams was completely left off a Boston writer's ballot), and the Yankees and Brooklyn Dodgers played an exciting seven-game World Series. The Series featured Cookie Lavagetto's pinch-hit double with two out in the ninth to break up Floyd Bevens' no-hitter in Game 4, which gave the Dodgers the victory, and Al Gionfriddo's magnificent catch off DiMaggio's bat in Game 6, concluding with the Yanks winning 5-2 in Game 7.

Most importantly, though, was Jackie Robinson's breakthrough season that saw him win Rookie of the Year, and open the flood gates for Willie Mays, Hank Aaron, and all the other great African-American ballplayers that followed.
Gary Kraus
Playa del Rey, Calif.

10. 1908 (8 letters)
Baseball has never seen pennant races like 1908. The top three teams in each league were within one game of each other. Never again would baseball see so many teams competing for so few postseason spots.

Add in the incredible drama of Merkle's boner (and the Christy Mathewson vs. Three Finger Brown duel in the one-game playoff), the emergence of Ty Cobb as a superstar, and the dominance of Mathewson (led the league in wins, saves, innings, strikeouts, ERA, shutouts, complete games, et al.) and you have a phenomenal season that should not be forgotten.
Chris Rivers
Washington D.C.

Page 2's List: Greatest baseball season ever

The List: Greatest single-season record

The List: Most beloved New York athlete of all-time

The List: Most underrated current baseball player

The List: Greatest sports wives of all-time

The List: Least likable football player

The List: Most beloved football players

The List: Least likable baseball players

The List: Most beloved baseball players

The List: Worst calls in sport history

The List: Worst free-agent signings

The List: Lopsided Trades

The List: Best owner in sports

Page 2's List: Best of the best nicknames

The List: Best sports moment nickname in history

The List: Best nicknames in boxing history

The List: Best nicknames in football history

The List: Best nicknames in baseball history

The List: Best nicknames in hockey history

The List: Best nicknames in basketball history

The List: Coolest athletes

The List: Best sports unit nickname in history

The List: Biggest upsets

The List: Best coaches

The List: Best feuds

The List: Worst baseball stadiums

The List: Best baseball stadiums

The List: The groupiest

Page 2 readers pick best baseball flicks

Copyright ©2001 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information are applicable to this site. Employment opportunities at