Top 10 overpaid and underpaid in MLS

May, 18, 2011
Joel Lindpere and Alvaro FernandezGetty ImagesJoel Lindpere and Alvaro Fernandez landed on our lists for the most underpaid and most overpaid players, respectively, in MLS.

As it does every year, the Major League Soccer Players' Union has released the salaries of every player on the books in MLS. And, as usual, there were plenty of surprises.

So here are's 2011 10 most underpaid and overpaid players, in no particular order:

(Salaries are base salaries plus guaranteed compensation for 2011 season.)


Omar Bravo, F, KC, $170,000

Bravo makes a fairly hefty salary for MLS standards, but considering what other international-caliber players make in this league, he is a bargain. And he scored twice in his debut before getting injured in his second game.

Diego Chaves, F, CHI, $45,000

After a solid career in Uruguay and Mexico, the Fire snapped Chaves up for a shade over minimum wage. He rewarded them with a goal in each of his first three starts and another in his sixth.

Omar Cummings, F, COL, $89,188

The Jamaican striker was the best forward in the league last season, leading the Rapids to the title. He has yet to get going this year, but his salary is still only a fraction of his worth.

Fabian Espindola, F, RSL, $75,000

The lively forward has proven himself as a quality MLS player.

George John, D, DAL, $42,000

For the moment, John is best-known as the man to score the own goal that lost his team the 2010 MLS Cup. That was an unfortunate moment, as he's one of the league's better defenders.

Kosuke Kimura, D, COL, $63,525

Kimura, like Cummings, has yet to get his payday, as he was drafted by the Rapids when his career was a long shot. He has emerged as one of the league's elite right backs -- for backup-player money.

Joel Lindpere, M, NY, $125,000

The little-known Lindpere didn't take long to announce himself to MLS last year, when he was the Red Bulls' well-deserved MVP. In spite of the star power assembled around him, he is still one of the most important players on the team.

Sanna Nyassi, M, COL, $42,000

A right winger who has twice overcome malaria, Nyassi is one of the better wide players around.

Tim Ream, D, NY, $62,625

In a much-heralded rookie class of 2010, Ream was the best defender by some distance. Now he is one of the best center backs in the league.

Mauro Rosales, M, SEA, $42,000

In the early 2000s, he was one of the world's most promising right wingers, having won the U-20 World Cup and Olympics with Argentina. The Sounders managed to snap him up for the league minimum. He paid quick dividends, getting three assists in his first four starts.


Joe Cannon, GK, VAN, $209,756

The hugely experienced Cannon was supposed to fortify the expansion team's defense. Instead, he rides the bench.

Julian de Guzman, M, TOR, $1,910,746

After a good career in the Bundesliga and La Liga, Guzman commanded an enormous salary from Toronto. But he has offered almost nothing in return.

Dilly Duka, M, CLB, $223,000

Columbus was excited about drafting Duka in 2010. But he has shown very little so far.

Emmanuel Ekpo, M, CLB, $222,250

With the departure of Guillermo Barros Schelotto, the burden fell on Ekpo to supply the Crew's offense this year. So far: zero assists and zero goals.

Alvaro Fernandez, M, SEA, $366,666

Although Fernandez is finally showing his ability this year, his salary and the hefty transfer sum the Sounders paid for him are still way out of proportion.

Caleb Folan, F, COL, $203,374

Other than one two-goal game, the Englishman has yet to justify his price tag.

Fred, M, DC, $157,750

In his fifth season, the Brazilian enigma has yet to reveal himself as a reliable asset.

Dejan Jakovic, D, DC, $201,643

They don't come much more gaffe-prone than Jakovic.

Nate Jaqua, F, SEA, $211,000

Jaqua had a good 2009 for Seattle, but has contributed little since.

Kei Kamara, F, KC, $202,500

The king of misses has amused us with blunders such as these. Kansas City doesn't look much better, given what it pays him.

Leander Schaerlaeckens

Contributing writer,
Leander Schaerlaeckens is a contributing writer for He has previously written for The Guardian, The Washington Times and UPI.


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?