On Wednesday, ESPN's "First Take" debated whether Eli Manning is an elite quarterback. Former Giants QB Phil Simms was critical of Manning's play, saying that he wasn't a player who could make an unbelievable play by himself. Skip Bayless thinks Simms is out of bounds, as Manning's résumé (two Super Bowl wins in which he made a number of excellent clutch plays) stands on its own. Rob Parker thinks Simms has something of a point, but believes he's overreacting to Manning's less-than-spectacular past two games. What's your take?

Comment »