Big Ten picks rewind: Week 4

Four weeks into the season, and it's still neck and neck. Brian Bennett and I differed on two predictions in Week 3, each getting one right and whiffing on the other. There weren't too many surprises around the conference.


Adam Rittenberg: 9-1, 40-6 (.870)

Brian Bennett: 9-1, 40-6 (.870)

Here's one last look at the Week 4 predictions made by us and our guest picker, Garret Olsen from Madison, Wis.

It's rewind time ...

San Jose State at Minnesota

  • Brian Bennett's pick: San Jose State 24, Minnesota 20

  • Adam Rittenberg's pick: Minnesota 27, San Jose State 24

  • Actual score: Minnesota 43, San Jose State 24

  • 20-20 hindsight: We both nailed San Jose State's score and underestimated the Gophers' offense, despite the absence of top quarterback Philip Nelson. San Jose State quarterback David Fales (439 pass yards, 3 TDs) performed well, as expected. Minnesota exceeded my prediction of 200 rushing yards and three touchdowns with 353 rushing yards and six scores.

Florida A&M at Ohio State

  • Bennett's pick: Ohio State 63, FAMU 10

  • Rittenberg's pick: Ohio State 59, FAMU 7

  • Actual score: Ohio State 76, FAMU 0

  • 20-20 hindsight: The mismatch turned out to be even more lopsided than we thought, as Ohio State scored 34 first-quarter points and 55 points in the first half. Buckeyes RBs Jordan Hall and Carlos Hyde had only two combined touchdowns, four fewer than my prediction. Quarterback Kenny Guiton fired a team-record six touchdown passes.

Western Michigan at Iowa

Maine at Northwestern

  • Bennett's pick: Northwestern 45, Maine 17

  • Rittenberg's pick: Northwestern 48, Maine 13

  • Actual score: Northwestern 35, Maine 21

  • 20-20 hindsight: We expected more from a Northwestern offense that had flexed its muscles in the first three games. Wildcats safety Ibraheim Campbell couldn't continue his streak of interceptions, as Bennett predicted he would. Only two Wildcats rushers reached the end zone, three fewer than my prediction, and freshman RB Warren Long wasn't one of them.

Michigan State at Notre Dame

  • Bennett's pick: Notre Dame 17, Michigan State 10

  • Rittenberg's pick: Notre Dame 19, Michigan State 17

  • Actual score: Notre Dame 17, Michigan State 13

  • 20-20 hindsight: One of our better predictions as Bennett nailed Notre Dame's score. The Irish didn't have a special-teams touchdown, as he predicted. I correctly pegged Michigan State to take an early lead, but neither of us forecast the pass-interference fest that took place in South Bend.

South Dakota State at Nebraska

  • Bennett's pick: Nebraska 38, South Dakota State 10

  • Rittenberg's pick: South Dakota State 59, South Dakota State 14

  • Actual score: Nebraska 59, South Dakota State 20

  • 20-20 hindsight: I nailed Nebraska's score and nearly pegged the combined passing touchdowns total for Tommy Armstrong and Ron Kellogg III (they had two, one shy of my prediction). Huskers RB Imani Cross did most of his damage in the first quarter, not the second. Nebraska DE Randy Gregory had an interception and two tackles for loss, but no forced fumble, as Brian predicted.

Kent State at Penn State

  • Bennett's pick: Penn State 28, Kent State 10

  • Rittenberg's pick: Penn State 31, Kent State 20

  • Actual score: Penn State 34, Kent State 0

  • 20-20 hindsight: We both came close on Penn State's score but underestimated the ability of the Lions' defense to bounce back from its struggles against UCF. Lions RB Zach Zwinak had three rushing touchdowns, one more than Brian predicted for him. There were no Christian Hackenberg-Allen Robinson scoring connections, as I predicted, but Lions DE Deion Barnes finally showed up a little.

Purdue at Wisconsin

  • Bennett's pick: Wisconsin 42, Purdue 14

  • Rittenberg's pick: Wisconsin 34, Purdue 21

  • Actual score: Wisconsin 41, Purdue 10

  • 20-20 hindsight: A strong score prediction from Brian, who also correctly pegged Badgers RBs James White and Melvin Gordon both to eclipse 100 rush yards. Gordon (16 carries, 147 yards) came up four carries and 33 yards shy of my predicted totals for him.

Michigan at Connecticut

  • Bennett's pick: Michigan 38, Connecticut 9

  • Rittenberg's pick: Michigan 35, Connecticut 17

  • Actual score: Michigan 24, Connecticut 21

  • 20-20 hindsight: Like the Wolverines and their fans, neither of us saw another near disaster coming as Michigan invaded venerable Rentschler Field on Saturday night. Michigan QB Devin Gardner had three more turnovers, one of which Connecticut returned for a touchdown, and only one score of his own, falling well shy of Brian's prediction (4 TDs, 1 turnover). I had Gardner for no turnovers, but RB Fitz Toussaint (120 rush yards, 2 TDs) came close to my prediction (130 rush yards, 2 TDs).

Missouri at Indiana

  • Bennett's pick: Missouri 48, Indiana 42

  • Rittenberg's pick: Indiana 41, Missouri 37

  • Actual score: Missouri 45, Indiana 28

  • 20-20 hindsight: Brian had the correct winner and came close on Missouri's score, correctly forecasting a big game for Tigers QB James Franklin (343 pass yards). Indiana RB Tevin Coleman rushed for one touchdown, not the two I had predicted, and the Hoosiers' offense struggled much more than I thought it would.

You've seen how we performed. Now it's time to check on our guest picker, Garret.

San Jose State 35, Minnesota 34

Ohio State 45, Florida A&M 7

Iowa 28, Western Michigan 14

Northwestern 55, Maine 10

Notre Dame 17, Michigan State 10

Nebraska 42, South Dakota State 21

Penn State 33, Kent State 24

Wisconsin 49, Purdue 17

Michigan 34, Connecticut 13

Missouri 42, Indiana 38

Garret's picks mirrored Brian's, so he also finished at 9-1. He had some good score predictions like Purdue-Wisconsin and Notre Dame-Michigan State and, like us, whiffed on others like Michigan-Connecticut and Maine-Northwestern. A strong effort in a relatively easy week. Wonder if Garret really is Brian? Hmmm ...

Who's our next guest picker? Tell us why you should be the choice here and here.