When the whistle blows too often

Joey CrawfordJesse D. Garrabrant/NBAE/Getty Images

In Game 4, referees Joe Crawford, Bill Kennedy and Greg Willard (behind Rondo) took center stage.

Following Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Finals, NBA fans were outraged that the team of officials working the game -- a team that included Bill Kennedy and Joey Crawford, two guys unafraid to make "the big call" -- had too big an impact on the game.

Too much controversy. Too many whistles, offensive fouls and stoppages. Not enough basketball!

And most importantly, the thinking went, keep the players on the court. Virtually every top player in Game 4 wrestled with foul trouble, and both LeBron James and Paul Pierce fouled out entirely.

But the video shows that the officials had no choice but to become central to the game. With one physical play after another, the players dared the referees to stop them. A by-the-book referee could have called multiple fouls on almost every possession.

We have talked a lot about flopping -- players pretending there is a foul when there really isn't. Also alive in the NBA, and particularly this playoff series is the opposite of that: players fouling the heck out of each other while pretending nothing's happening at all.

For example: James drew a key offensive foul on Kevin Garnett when Garnett grabbed James' arm with both hands to prevent him from rotating to a Rajon Rondo drive. Garnett kept his arms in. From the baseline official's point of view it looked like nothing was wrong, which is why that kind of grabbing is typical. This play ended differently only because James, in an effort to wrench his arm free, yanked Garnett to the ground, virtually demanding the referees react.

Earlier in the fourth, Joel Anthony was whistled for pushing Garnett in the back as the two fought for a rebound. It was a good call, except at the same time Anthony was nudging Garnett, Paul Pierce was shoving Anthony in the back with two hands. Calling it either way would have simultaneously been perfectly legitimate and in no way entirely accurate.

By the final period the video shows these types of plays were happening all over the court.

What's a referee to do? That they called a lot of fouls hardly seems to proper complaint. That they called the game in a way where players fouled constantly is the bigger concern.

From the league's point of view, the priority, surely is to present fans with a more exciting brand of basketball, with stars on the court as long as their coaches want them there, and with teams actually scoring baskets now and again instead of succumbing to the rigors of playoff physicality. The two teams combined for six total points in all of overtime.

So, what is your solution? It seems clear the NBA needs two things, which at first may seem contradictory:

  • Stronger discouragement: Players foul so much because it works. Either because referees are reluctant to call every by-the-book foul, and/or because the penalties aren't harsh enough, it's a good strategy to play harder than the rulebook allows. So players grab, hold, shove and slap, all the while daring the referees to expel them, which they only sometimes do.

  • Different punishments: Free-throws and foul trouble punish players and teams, to some degree. But they punish fans most of all, making the game more boring every way imaginable. 1) Free throws are the least entertaining part of the game. 2) People tune in to see superstars, which they don't get when the rules remove them from the field. 3) Fouls, called and not, prevent a lot of the game's most exciting plays, especially dunks, fast breaks and challenges at the rim.

We find ourselves needing more ways to get players not to foul, but at the same time less of the old punishment for fouling. In short, we need new ideas. New incentives to get players more focused on playing basketball and less focused on the referee games.

Sounds like a job for HoopIdea.

What do you suggest?


You can give us your ideas and talk with us and other fans in the following places:

And for the truly ambitious: Shoot a short video of yourself explaining your HoopIdea, upload it to YouTube and share the link with us on Twitter or Google+.