MADISON, Wis. -- Wisconsin escaped an upset bid by Cal Poly of the Football Championship Subdivision, mounting a late comeback and capitalizing on three missed extra points to win 36-35 in overtime Saturday on John Clay's second touchdown of the game.
The victory improves Wisconsin to 7-5 and makes it likely the Badgers will be invited to a bowl game, a bittersweet accomplishment for a team that began the season with expectations of contending for a Big Ten title and at one point climbed into the top 10 in the rankings.
Wisconsin looked headed for another disappointing loss midway through the fourth quarter as James Noble punched it in from 2 yards to give Cal Poly a 29-21 lead. But Andrew Gardner missed his second extra point of the game, leaving an opening for the Badgers.
Wisconsin quarterback Dustin Sherer took advantage of the opportunity, marching Wisconsin 89 yards in nine plays. The drive was capped by P.J. Hill's 3-yard touchdown run. Wisconsin again handed off to Hill on the 2-point try, tying up the game.
The Mustangs had a chance to win the game with 12 seconds left after bringing in sophomore Jake West, who handles kickoffs, to try a 46-yard field goal. But West, whose long field in high school was 32 yards, came up about 15 yards short.
But Gardner missed again, this time clanking the extra point try off the right upright.
Wisconsin gave the ball to Clay three times on its OT possession, and he scored from 6 yards out. Philip Welch kicked the extra point to seal the win. Clay rushed for 107 yards.
Cal Poly, ranked No. 3 in the FCS coaches poll, used its wing-T formation to rush for 276 yards, the most Wisconsin has given up this season. Dally led the Mustangs with 213 total yards and two scores, one through the air and one on the ground.
For Wisconsin, Hill's 59 yards rushing put him over 1,000 yards for the third straight season, only the second Badger to accomplish that.
Miami Hurricanes sticking with quarterback Tyler Van Dyke despite rough outing vs. Middle Tennessee State
Miami head coach Mario Cristobal said Monday that Tyler Van Dyke would remain the starting quarterback despite being benched in the Hurricanes' 45-31 loss to Middle Tennessee State University two weeks ago.
Capital One Fan Vote: Which unbeaten top-10 team was most impressive Saturday?
Which unbeaten team caught your eye the most? Alabama, Clemson, Michigan or Oklahoma State?
College football Week 5 recap: Best highlights and takeaways
Week 5 brought us upsets, highlight-reel plays and major statement victories from some surprise unbeaten teams.
Who will make the College Football Playoff?
With help from the Allstate Playoff Predictor, you can play out the 2022 season and see how likely it is that top contenders will reach the College Football Playoff.
Paul Chryst fired: Who will replace Wisconsin's football coach?
Jim Leonhard is one of the top young defensive minds in college football. Will he take over full time at Wisconsin? Or could Wisconsin lure someone like Kansas' Lance Leipold or Baylor's Dave Aranda?
College football's biggest changes through the first five weeks of the season
The top three is still the top three, but plenty of teams have been better than we might have expected. Bill Connelly sorts it all out.