After Chandler Stanton's 45-yard field goal put the Mountaineers on top with 5:45 to play, the defense held but Robert Lefevre's 45-yard punt pinned Appalachian State on its 8-yard line with four minutes remaining.
Noel then carried five-straight times, the last two 41- and 22-yard bursts that put the Mountaineers (3-1) on the Marshall 5. Quarterback Chase Brice then knelt down three times to run out the clock.
After the second of Brice's touchdowns, Rasheen Ali had a 97-yard kickoff return to give Marshall a 20-14 lead. But Brice capped a third long drive with a touchdown two seconds before halftime to put Appalachian State back on top 21-20.
Ali's touchdown run gave Marshall (2-2) a 30-21 lead entering the fourth quarter.
The former conference rivals from the FCS days were meeting for the second time as FBS schools with Marshall winning 17-7 last season.
NFL, college football betting market watch: Line movement, early action and bookmaker insights
David Purdum gives an update on where the money lies in Week 7 NFL games, which teams are popular tickets, college insights and more.
College football teams that have gotten the most production from underclassmen
From Ohio State, with running back TreVeyon Henderson, to Oklahoma and Florida, Pro Football Focus looks at which schools are getting the biggest boost from underclassmen.
Stanford Steve and The Bear: Week 8 college football picks, bets, nuggets
What's in store for Week 8 of the college football season? The fellas break it down with their best bets, parlays worth playing and more.
The best of USC's Drake London is still to come
Drake London is a rising star at wide receiver, and he hasn't even reached his full potential.
College football Week 8: Kenny Pickett against Clemson, A Big 12 test and more
High praise for Pittsburgh's Kenny Pickett, a top 10 road underdog in the Big 12 and more ahead of Week 7.
Indiana tries to put season on track against No. 5 Ohio St
Indiana spent the last year pointing to this week's Ohio State game as a measuring stick.