WASHINGTON -- The NBA's steroids policy was branded
"pathetic" and "a joke" by lawmakers Thursday, and the head of
a congressional panel said he will propose a law creating
drug-testing standards for the four major professional sports
House Government Reform Committee chairman Tom Davis, R-Va.,
opened a hearing focusing on the NBA by saying he'll produce a
uniform testing bill next week. Davis promised the legislation he's
drafting with ranking Democrat Henry Waxman of California and Sen.
John McCain, R-Ariz., "will have more teeth than other bills
Davis didn't go into specifics, but Waxman said their
legislation would follow the Olympic model and would call for a
two-year ban for a first offense and a lifetime ban for a second
Those mirror the penalties in the Drug Free Sports Act,
introduced last month by Rep. Cliff Stearns, R-Fla., chairman of a
House Energy and Commerce subcommittee conducting a separate
inquiry into steroid use.
Testifying before that panel Thursday, NFL commissioner Paul
Tagliabue said Stearns' bill "is not appropriate to be enacted in
its present form. ... At least as it applies to the NFL, we feel
that it is unnecessary."
At the same time, in a nearby hearing room, Davis' committee was
directing the sort of criticism at NBA commissioner David Stern and
union leader Billy Hunter that it heaped on Major League Baseball
officials in a March 17 hearing.
Since then, though, commissioner Bud Selig has proposed
toughening baseball's drug policy, including punishing first
offenders with 50-game suspensions instead of 10-day bans, issuing
lifetime suspensions for a third offense, and banning amphetamines.
"Our investigation already has spawned results, evidenced most
profoundly by Major League Baseball's abrupt about-face on the need
for more stringent testing," Davis said.
He said the bill he'll propose would cover baseball, the NBA,
the NFL and the NHL.
Washington Wizards guard Juan Dixon and Houston Rockets trainer
Keith Jones also testified Thursday, and both said they didn't know
of any steroid use in the NBA.
"Certainly, the NBA is not suffering under the same cloud of
steroid-use suspicion that has been hovering over other
professional sports," Davis said.
But, he continued, "How do we know for sure there's no steroid
problem in the NBA if its testing policies are so weak?"
Waxman called the NBA's policy "simply inadequate." Rep.
William Lacy Clay, a Missouri Democrat, called it "a joke." Rep.
Elijah Cummings, a Maryland Democrat, said the NBA's policy is
"weaker than the NFL or MLB's." And Rep. Stephen Lynch, a
Massachusetts Democrat, said: "It is, in my opinion, rather
Stern repeated what he told Stearns' subcommittee Wednesday: He
has told Hunter that he wants to add more in-season tests, double
the penalty for a first offense to 10 games, and kick players out
of the league for a third positive test.
"The union supports some changes," Hunter said.
That didn't draw much enthusiasm from lawmakers, with Indiana
Republican Mark Souder telling Stern: "It's a little too little,
and it's a little too late."
Stern and Hunter said the issue will be addressed in
negotiations to replace their collective bargaining agreement,
which expires June 30. The league broke off talks Wednesday, and
Stern painted a bleak picture Thursday.
"I'm not confident, because we're confounded as to how we can
make a deal at this point," he said after testifying. "I'm
concerned that there will be a lockout."
During the hearing, Lynch pointed out that the NBA's current
program calls for in-season testing of veteran players only if
there is "reasonable cause." Noting that one of the effects of
steroid use is violent behavior, the congressman asked Hunter
whether the melee involving players and fans at a game in November
between the Indiana Pacers and Detroit Pistons constituted such
That led to the most contentious exchange of the day, with
Hunter calling Lynch's question "a quantum leap."
"I'm not saying it was caused by steroid use. I'm saying you
don't know," Lynch said.
They went back and forth, interrupting each other, before Stern
"On behalf of the players of the National Basketball
Association, I would like to say that the guilt that you seek to
attribute to them on the basis of this policy is ill-taken and very
unfair," Stern said.
That drew a retort from Lynch, to which Stern responded: "It's
a free country, and I would just like to disagree with your
approach, that's all."
In Stearns' hearing, the NFL generally was commended for its
drug-testing policy. Tagliabue, though, called the proposed
legislation's punishments "draconian" and said the bill "seems
to have disadvantages that outweigh the advantages."
But he also said he would support it if changes were made,
including shortening the suspensions, keeping testing jurisdiction
out of the hands of an international agency, and making sure the
league maintains its collective bargaining authority.