When it comes right down to it, which is more difficult: shooting a final-round 59 to win a PGA event by one stroke or hitting a walk-off home run to complete the cycle? It's not an easy question to answer, but it's one our panel had to face.
Golfer Stuart Appleby and Rockies slugger Carlos Gonzalez battled it out for the No. 1 and No. 2 spots, and in the end, Appleby's 59 slightly edged out Gonzalez's cycle. Did the panel make the right decision with the top two? What about the other 18 athletes who made the list? See anyone who was placed way too high or unjustly low or whom we flat-out missed? Now is your chance to let us know below!
And don't forget, you can visit the Cross-Sport Power Rankings page on Tuesdays to see the latest rankings each week.