Updated: October 27, 2010, 1:07 PM ET

Does Asia swing make sense for the PGA Tour?

Harig By Bob Harig

With little warning but plenty of fanfare, the Fall Series has given us two golf tournament endings that would hold their own, regardless of the time of year.

[+] EnlargeFowler
Steve Dykes/Getty ImagesRickie Fowler is among the PGA Tour players heading to the Far East this week for the CIMB Asia Pacific Classic Malaysia.

Rocco Mediate made four eagles on four straight days at the Frys.com Open, including holing out from the fairway on the 71st hole for a 1-stroke victory -- his first in eight years.

Then a week later, in near darkness, Jonathan Byrd -- whose PGA Tour card was hardly secured -- became the first player in tour history to win a tournament by making a hole-in-one in a sudden-death playoff.

Good stuff, even during golf's doldrums.

Now, however, riding this mini-wave of momentum, the PGA Tour takes a two-week break before concluding its official money season at the Children's Miracle Network Classic at Walt Disney World, adding to the maddening nature in which the golf season mercifully comes to an end.

Follow this. After the FedEx Cup season concluded with Jim Furyk's stirring victory -- and FedEx Cup title -- at the Tour Championship, the tour moved on to its Fall Series, where those not eligible for the FedEx Cup got to play again for the first time in more than a month.

The Viking Classic was played the same week as the Ryder Cup, followed by the McGladrey Classic, the Fys.com Open and Justin Timberlake Shriners Hospital for Children Open.

Now comes that two-week break so the PGA Tour can take its product overseas.

This week's event, the Asia Pacific Classic in Malaysia, is the tour's foray into sanctioning a tournament in Asia. The motives for such a move remain murky when there are plenty of problems to address on the home front. Certainly trying to open new doors in an emerging growth market is behind this endeavor.

But it's hard to see the tournament as anything more than a big-money perk that might get a few guys over to the region before next week's HSBC Champions, the fourth World Golf Championship event of the year.

While Ernie Els described it as "a momentous occasion for the PGA Tour and Southeast Asia," it is difficult to envision going beyond this, certainly not like the European Tour's attempts to branch out around the world.

"The European Tour has shown how to do it," Els said in Malaysia. "Whether the U.S. PGA Tour will do that, too, may be unlikely. It's a very long way from the U.S. to Asia so any more golf tournaments over here. … it's going to be tough for players to travel. They have a full schedule anyway in the U.S. but it will be interesting to see what the commissioner [Tim Finchem] thinks about it."

Luke Donald also applauded the move, saying it is good for the game for high-profile U.S. players and those who play the PGA Tour to be showcased abroad.

"The only problem I see is that there are so many good events to play in and it might tend to make other events a little bit diluted," Donald said.

Well, that is actually a problem already domestically. And when a player sets up his schedule, he is looking typically at the number of tournaments played, not whether or not they are official. A tournament appearance this week likely means dropping one somewhere else.

The Asia Pacific event, while co-sponsored by the PGA Tour along with the Asian Tour, has no official significance. Prize money will not count on the money list; a victory will not be official or bring with it a two-year exemption. It has just 40 players with a whopping $6 million purse and no cut.

The field is derived from the top 25 available on the final FedEx Cup standings, the top 10 from the Asian Tour and five sponsor exemptions. Among those who made the journey were Rickie Fowler and Retief Goosen.

All of them are sticking around for next week's HSBC event in China, which also is not official money. But a victory counts if you are a PGA Tour member. Of course, both tournaments award world ranking points, with next week's tournament in China setting up as a nice battle between Tiger Woods, Lee Westwood, Martin Kaymer and Phil Mickelson for No. 1.

Meanwhile, the rank and file must sweat it out for two more weeks before the season finale in the shadow of the Magic Kingdom.

Young champion

You could see this coming, more than a year ago, when Italy's Matteo Manassero, playing in the British Open as winner of the British Amateur, impressed Tom Watson. They were grouped for the first two days, along with Sergio Garcia.

"He's a beautiful putter, but he's also a great striker of the ball," Watson said at Turnberry, where he would famously lose in a playoff to Stewart Cink. "And he knows how to hit the ball. He put the ball in play all the time. He was rarely out of play.

"I was very impressed with him. In fact, I told him on the way down the 18th hole, I said. 'Don't change anything, just keep enjoying the game and you'll get there.'"

Manassero went on to finish tied for 13th at age 16. Now 17, he is a champion on the European Tour, the youngest to win a tournament on that circuit after his victory Sunday at the Castello Masters in Spain.

"He seems to be cut from the same exciting mold as Seve Ballesteros or Rory McIlroy," said Ireland's Peter Lawrie, who tied for third in the tournament. "He has that little bit of an aura about him and seems like a superstar going forward.

"But he also hangs around with the other lads [on tour] and is an all-round nice guy. He's a lovely fellow and deserves any success he gets."

Manassero suddenly has opportunities, including a spot in next week's HSBC Champions in China -- if he can secure a visa.

Meanwhile, there came a question as to what he would do with the prize money, which comes to more than $500,000.

"I'm not old enough to drive and I don't have a girlfriend so I really have nothing to spend the money on," he said.


Jose Maria Olazabal is the obvious choice to be the next European Ryder Cup captain. He served as a vice captain for Nick Faldo in 2008, was a last-minute addition to Colin Montgomerie's team of vice captains this year, and has an exemplary playing record, with seven Ryder Cup appearances. And he has received the endorsement of Monty for the role in 2012 at Medinah outside Chicago.

But Olazabal said last week he is unsure he will accept the position if offered due to health issues that have kept him from playing much golf in the past year. Olazabal has rheumatism which has limited him to just two events in the past 12 months. And he feels he needs to be playing in order to be Ryder Cup captain.

"If the committee decides it's going to be me as the next captain, I need to talk with them beforehand to see how we can solve the possible inconvenience that I may not be on the tour playing that much," Olazabal said. "If they appoint me, I somehow have to be close to the players, somehow be able to compete alongside them, talk to them, to see how they think, and just be close to the tour through the qualifying process."

Olazabal's intentions are noble, but does the role of the captain really require him to be alongside the players competing? That was hardly the case with Faldo two years ago. And American Paul Azinger was not on tour every week. Neither were Montgomerie or U.S. captain Corey Pavin this year.

A captain certainly wants to get a feel for how his players are competing, but this is another example of the task being overrated. Unless the criteria changes, Europe has nine players automatically make the team. There is nothing Olazabal can do by playing alongside them that will change that. He's got three at-large picks to make, which he can do by following tournaments in person, on television, and through media accounts.

It hardly seems that if Olazabal is unable to play, but is fit enough to be captain otherwise, that he should give up the post for those reasons.

"It would hurt me to say no, but if it is the right decision, my conscience will be clear," he said.

Bob Harig covers golf for ESPN.com. He can be reached at BobHarig@gmail.com.


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?