Johnson won in 2012, lost to Jordan Spieth in a three-way playoff last year, and tied for second in 2009.
Stricker won three straight beginning in 2009, tied for fifth two years ago and tied for 10th last year.
After 36 holes of this year's Deere, Johnson is a co-leader, and Stricker is tied for sixth, three strokes back.
The two Midwesterners -- Johnson is from Cedar Rapids, Iowa, while Stricker hails from Madison, Wisconsin -- go out of their way to say there's no rivalry. And Johnson gives the nod of supremacy to Stricker.
"I've won once. He's won three times," Johnson said. "I don't think it's a debate. Twenty-five years from now, nobody is going to remember who finished second, third or fourth."
Stricker kidded, "I thought I was the man here," adding he felt playing at TPC Deere Run was something of a home weekend, even though Madison is three hours away.
"We don't have a tournament in Milwaukee anymore, and this is the closest thing to home, I guess," Stricker said. "It looks like we could be playing this in Madison."
Johnson shot 4-under 67 in the afternoon despite two bogeys in his last four holes. That dropped him into a tie with McGirt.
McGirt, 35, is looking for his first PGA Tour victory. He added a 66 to his opening 64, but like Johnson, he finished with a bogey. McGirt's best finish this year is a tie for sixth in the Northern Trust Open at Riviera. Since then, he's had one top 10 and has missed the cut in seven of 14 tournaments.
McGirt is winless on the PGA Tour in 111 starts, most of them in the past four years. His best finishes are a pair of ties for second in the Canadian Open, in 2012 and 2013.
Asked how he'd gotten to 12-under and the lead on Friday, he said, "I couldn't tell you what happened."
Four birdies in a row and seven in a stretch of nine holes happened.
One thing McGirt hasn't been doing well recently is sinking putts, but he's needed only 24 in each of the first two rounds.
"For some reason I'm able to see the line this week," McGirt said. "I feel I've putted better the last few weeks and haven't holed anything."
Bowditch opened his round with an eagle 3 on the 10th hole en route to a 67, while Wagner made it to 12-under before a bogey on his last hole.
Stricker matched McGirt's 5-under 30 on Deere Run's front nine to finish his round.
Hamilton, who grew up in the area, used a 69 to get to 133, while Moore shot 67 and Sabbatini shot 70.
Spieth was five strokes back of the leaders through 36 holes thanks to a 64 for 7-under 135. He was five back after two rounds last year.
Johnson's success in his home tournament has given him a comfort level absent previously, when he missed the cut three times in seven years and didn't finish better than 20th.
"I've grasped and embraced the fact I'm going to have a lot of friends outside the ropes, and it's terrific," Johnson said. "They don't care if I shoot 62 or 82. They're still going to be on my side.
"Trying to play for them may have been part of the issue years ago, but not anymore."
Stricker, 109 under par in 22 rounds since 2009 at Deere Run, got within sight of the leaders with his 30 on the course's front nine to finish his round.
"At least I kept pace," Stricker said. "This was an important day for me. I didn't go out with a specific number in mind, but I knew I needed something good."
Stricker won three straight at Deere Run starting in 2009 and has tied for fifth and 10th place, respectively, the past two years.
"I know how to play it, I guess," Stricker said. "There's a lot of short iron shots, which plays into my game, and I seem to putt the ball really well, too."
The cut fell at 2-under-par 140, leaving 77 players for the weekend. Former world No. 1 David Duval withdrew after an opening 81.