Off Base

Jim Caple

MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Players
Transactions
Injuries: AL | NL
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
Message Board
CLUBHOUSE


FEATURES
Playoff Schedule
News Wire
Daily Glance
Power Alley
History
MLB Insider


THE ROSTER
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Wednesday, August 13
 
Save it already: Closers way too overvalued

By Jim Caple
ESPN.com

Eric Gagne broke Jose Mesa's major league record when he successfully converted his 39th consecutive save opportunity over the weekend. This isn't that surprising given Gagne's high-90s smoke and the fact that he has inherited only five runners all season.

That's right. Five inherited runners in 57 games and 59 innings. Mike Tyson's family is in line for a bigger inheritance.

Of Gagne's 39 saves, only four times did he enter the game with a runner on base. Only twice did he enter the game with a runner on base and a one-run lead. Only once did he enter with a runner in scoring position (and that was with a four-run lead and two outs in the ninth).

Eric Gagne
Eric Gagne is 43-for-43 in save opportunities this season.

I'm not saying Gagne is not a good pitcher -- he quite obviously is a very good pitcher and he has been extraordinary successful in his role. Nor am I saying that he's pampered more than any other closer -- he hasn't been. And that's just the problem. The role too seldom requires Gagne or any other closer to do anything truly valuable with their talents.

Closer is the most overrated and overvalued role in baseball.

Remember when the top relievers used to be known as firemen and wore those outrageous fire helmets in publicity photos? These days, closers are never anywhere near a fire. They're more like the old guy who sits around the firehouse waiting to show off the hook and ladder truck to the elementary class field trip.

Closers are supposedly the best relievers on the staff yet they are never brought into the game during crucial situations in the sixth or seventh inning, and only rarely in the eighth. The bases could be loaded with nobody out, a one-run lead, the heart of the order coming up and the smoke detectors blaring in the restrooms, but the closer isn't going anywhere near the mound. He's going to sit around that bullpen chewing sunflower seeds until the ninth inning when the fire is out, the ashes are smoldering and no one is on base.

I'm sorry, that's not fair. Most closers don't just sit around the bullpen until the ninth inning. Most of them don't even bother going out there for the first six innings, preferring to stay in the clubhouse "preparing'' by watching videos, listening to music and reading Maxim. The closer with more career saves than anyone else, Lee Smith, was notorious for sleeping in the trainers room before finally strolling out to the bullpen just in time to warm up for the ninth inning.

Closer is the only job in baseball that should come with a nite lite.

The save is the only occasion where managers regularly make moves based strictly on a statistic. If a team leads by three runs or less, he will bring his closer in to pitch the ninth inning. If a team leads by four runs or more, he will leave him in the bullpen to finish the crossword puzzle.

What's a six-letter word for underworked?

As good as Gagne is, more than half his saves came with a two-run lead or greater in the ninth inning and 14 came with a three-run lead or greater in the ninth. Where's the sense in that? If these guys are so darn good, wouldn't it be better to use a lesser reliever for a three-run/nobody-on situation and use the closer when the situation is dire? But that's not the way it works. Unless a manager lets his top reliever pile up the cheap saves to inflate his stats for arbitration, the writers are going to second-guess him, the closer is going to pout, his agent is going to call up to complain, frogs are going to fall from the sky, dogs and cats will sleep together and zombies will roam the earth.

Granted, there are closers who are worthy of their reputation, guys who are able to perform their job spectacularly year after year. Closers such as Mariano Rivera and Trevor Hoffman. But because the rules covering saves are so liberal, just about anyone can step in and do the job for a year or two. Look at Kaz Sasaki and Shigetoshi Hasegawa.

Sasaki is the Mariners' highest paid player and he was 1-1 with a 4.12 ERA, 10 saves and four blown saves when he broke his ribs tripping (wink, wink) over his suitcase. So what did the Mariners do? They slipped Hasegawa into the closer's role. And he's 11-for-11 in save chances. He hasn't allowed a run since moving into the role.

Rocky Biddle
Rocky Biddle has 28 saves for the Expos, but also has a 4.24 ERA.

Montreal's Rocky Biddle has 28 saves. Colorado's Jose Jimenez has 20 saves with a 6.00 ERA. Philadelphia's Mike Williams made the All-Star team while being a member of the Pittsburgh Pirates with a 6.44 ERA simply because he had 25 saves.

It's not like the closer is really doing anything besides eating up salary. Despite the evolution of closers, a "Total Baseball'' analysis found that late-inning leads were successfully protected at pretty much the same rate as they were 50 years ago.

Look, there was nothing wrong with the save when Chicago sportswriter Jerome Holtzman developed it in 1959 (it became an official stat a decade later). It was a nice stat that added a method to evaluating the otherwise overlooked reliever. But the way the save -- and the use of closers -- has evolved has cheapened the statistic.

Enough. It's time to save the save. If managers are letting a statistic manage them, it's time to change the statistic. It's time to increase the save's value by changing the rules for awarding it.

From now on, closers don't get a save for pitching the ninth inning with a three-run lead. From now on, his team must lead by no more than two runs. From now on, the hitter in the on-deck circle must at least represent the potential tying run at all times. From now on, no cheap saves. From now on, closers must work for a living.

From now on, if a closer gets a save, he must save something.

And as for Gagne's new record? Well, congratulations big guy. But if a record really was significant, it wouldn't have been held by Jose Mesa.

Jim Caple is a senior writer for ESPN.com.





 More from ESPN...
Jim Caple Archive



 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 
Daily email