Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries: AL | NL
Players
Power Alley
Free Agents
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Dave Campbell
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Joe Morgan
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Friday, November 8
 
Clemens' future home remains a question mark

By Bob Klapisch
Special to ESPN.com

The curtain is about to rise on the open-market bidding war for Roger Clemens, the six-time Cy Young Award winner who, at age 40, remains a billboard of physical fitness and angry fastballs. In theory, the free-agent universe should belong to Clemens, only seven wins away from his 300th career victory.

All the Rocket has to do is pick his next employer, right?

Not exactly.

Who should Yankees keep?
Andy Pettitte's elbow may be hanging together by a tendon the width of a Yankee pinstripe.

Roger Clemens is a free agent and may be willing to bolt to his home state of Texas and win his 300th game with the Rangers or Astros.

Jorge Posada, in the midst of a longterm contract, may be on the trade block, and he's not happy about that.

And the Yankees -- gasp! -- may actually have to watch their budget in 2003 (thank you, Sterling Hitchcock!), especially if they want to sign Japanese slugger Hideki Matsui.

If the Bronx Bombers can keep just one of the three, should be? Consider ...

Pettitte: The Yankees have to decide by Nov. 15 whether to pick up Pettitte's $11.5 million option for 2003. The hook is nobody knows the seriousness of Pettitte's elbow injury, which caused him to miss two months this past season and makes trading him extremely difficult.

Clemens: The Yankees already had to pay him a $10.3 million buyout. Do they want to pay him another $10 million to pitch? He's 40 years old ... but he's also still effective and just seven wins from 300.

Posada: He's one of the top three hitting catchers in baseball and is entering the second year of a five-year, $51 million deal. But he'll be 35 by the end of deal and the Yanks aren't happy with his defense.
--ESPN.com

In recent days, the number of potential suitors has dwindled and it's possible Clemens will return to the Yankees -- as much out of necessity as loyalty.

Then again, clubs which insist they can't afford or have no interest in Clemens -- like the Rangers and Red Sox -- could very well be testing agents Alan and Randy Hendricks, in hopes of lowering the Rocket's asking price.

"Only Roger Clemens and his agent will know what the market is for him," Yankees' GM Brian Cashman told the New York Daily News on Wednesday. Still, the Yankees know the Rocket won't accept much less than the $15 million a year he earned in both 2001 and 2002, and it's just as likely he'll ask for at least a two-year commitment from his new club.

So who's in the hunt? Who's likely to bid -- or not? Here's the early rundown.

Red Sox
Reason Clemens might sign: History, for one. It'd be a wonderful opportunity to say Take That to former GM Dan Duquette. In some ways, Clemens will be eternally linked to Fenway, where fans still feel more passionately about him than Yankee loyalists. Derek Jeter and Jason Giambi both eclipse Clemens' star power in New York.

One other factor: Pedro Martinez has strongly endorsed wooing Clemens, indicating there'd be no ego problems between the two aces in the same rotation.

Reason why Clemens won't sign: History, for one. It was bad enough for Clemens to renounce his Fenway citizenship to become a Blue Jay but becoming a Yankee, and prospering, is a debt Clemens will never be able to repay. True, the current Red Sox leadership had nothing to do with banishing Clemens, but traumas such as these linger forever.

Rangers
Reason why Clemens might sign: The Rocket wants to finish his career at home, in Texas, and what better place than with a team that desperately needs his right arm. Clemens has checked off every item on his career to-do list, and all that's left is that 300th win, which he'd like to achieve in front of family and friends.

Reason why Clemens won't sign: The Rangers lost close to $30 million last year, still paying for their mistake in overpaying Chan Ho Park and others, not to mention paying Alex Rodriguez. The last thing owner Tom Hicks wants is to further drain his bank account. GM John Hart might just be telling the truth when he says, "I don't see Texas as a player for Roger. We've had zero conversations with Roger's agent."

Roger Clemens
Roger Clemens was 13-6 with a 4.35 ERA in 29 starts in 2002.

Astros
Reason why Clemens might sign: The Astros offer the same feel-good dividend as the Rangers, allowing Clemens the chance to return to his roots. Owner Drayton McLane likes the Rocket and likes the idea of snaring this Texas homeboy away from the Rangers -- and the Yankees, of course. Whether the Astros could possibly afford Clemens is another story, however. It's the longest of longshots.

Reason why Clemens won't sign: Forget about the money issues, do you think Clemens wants for one second to sign with a National League team? That'd mean actually stepping in the batter's box every five days, and picking up the check for every high-and-tight fastball the Rocket ever lost control of. That could be hazardous to Clemens' health.

Mets
Reason why Clemens might sign: The Mets desperately need to make a power move after their disastrous 2002 season, and are already considering pursuing free agent Tom Glavine. Clemens would send an even larger message to disgruntled fans. In fact, it would be the ultimate wound inflicted upon the Yankees, stealing away the Rocket and throwing a huge party under George Steinbrenner's nose after the right-hander's 300th win.

Reason why Clemens won't sign: There's still too much unresolved anger between Clemens and Piazza, and as an organization, the Mets have never forgiven the Rocket for beaning their best player in 2000, fracturing his cheekbone. If the Rocket's inclined to pitch in New York in 2003, he'd just as soon avoid the bad chemistry he'd have to endure at Shea.

Yankees
Reason why Clemens might sign: It could be his sole alternative, especially if the Rangers and Red Sox can't cough up $12-$15 million a year. And let's face it, the Rocket wants to remain in the Bronx.

He's said so all along that he feels indebted to Steinbrenner for acquiring him and giving him the chance to finally win a World Championship, and he's not about to ignore that.

Reason why Clemens won't sign: It's possible the Yankees simply won't pursue the right-hander, despite Steinbrenner's personal affection for him.

There's talk of keeping the budget under $140 million next year, which means Cashman has to cut somewhere. The Yankees already have five other starters -- all of whom had lower ERAs than Clemens last year -- and members of the Tampa braintrust are asking Steinbrenner to remember the Rocket has been on the disabled list three of the last four seasons.

Despite the strength of this argument, though, Steinbrenner always has the last word. He might simply overrule his lieutenants and keep Clemens, no matter what it costs.

Bob Klapisch of The Record (Bergen County, N.J.) covers baseball for ESPN.com.







 More from ESPN...
Free agent Clemens officially files; Glavine plans visits
Roger Clemens filed for free ...

MLB free agents
Check out the list of ...

McAdam: AL East questions
Every team has questions ...

Bob Klapisch Archive

 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 
Daily email