Joe Morgan

Pitching Probables
Injuries: AL | NL
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
Message Board

Playoff Schedule
News Wire
Daily Glance
Power Alley
MLB Insider

Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
ESPN Auctions
Thursday, June 5
Updated: June 6, 4:19 PM ET
Corked-bat mistake happened to me once

By Joe Morgan
Special to

For all those who jumped to conclusions after Sammy Sosa was caught with a corked bat, it looks like Sosa's explanation was more correct than their accusations.

Sosa said he used the corked bat only for batting practice and picked it up by mistake in Tuesday night's game. Since then, all 76 of Sosa's bats that were confiscated after the incident have been X-rayed and found to be completely cork-free.

The five bats Sosa has given to the Hall of Fame also were found to be clean.
Moreover, the five bats Sosa has given to the Baseball Hall of Fame were X-rayed by us at the Hall (I'm the vice chairman of the Hall) and also found to be clean. These are the bats he used in achieving milestones such as his 500th home run.

Sosa's accomplishments should not be tarnished by this one incident, according to the statement released Thursday by the Hall. Some writers have suggested that Sosa's Hall credentials should now be questioned. I disagree with that. Sosa should be punished, but it hasn't been proved that this is anything more than an isolated incident.

Since Sosa's bats were demonstrated to be clean, I accept his explanation. In fact, I understand how a batter could use a corked bat by mistake -- because it happened to me once.

I had two or three corked bats, made for me by a carpenter, that I used for batting practice when I played with the San Francisco Giants in 1981. We used them because the cold conditions made our hands hurt during BP. The corked bat would soften the sting and protect your hands. I also used aluminum bats during batting practice, for the same reason.

One day, I forgot to take the corked bats back to my clubhouse locker after BP. During the game, one of my bats broke, and the bat boy brought a couple of other bats to me. I just grabbed one, because all my bats were the same. After I hit a fly ball to right field, I thought, "That didn't feel right." I went back to look at the bat, and sure enough -- it was the corked bat I had used in BP and forgotten to put away.

I had two or three corked bats that I used for batting practice in San Francisco in 1981.
What bothered me was that I could have used it accidentally that one time and it could have broken in two, as happened with Sosa. To me, the consequences were too great. So after that, I went back to using my regular bats for BP. As I recall, the clubhouse guy threw the corked bats away for me.

By the way, there's a debate about whether a corked bat actually causes a batted ball to travel farther. My experience was that corked bats did not make the ball go farther -- at least they didn't help me. I agree with ESPN analyst Bobby Valentine on this issue.

I also agree with ESPN analyst Harold Reynolds that it's possible that a corked-bat event like Sosa's could simply be a mistake. It isn't probable, but it's possible. I know, because it happened to me.

Chat Reminder: I'll answer your questions in an chat Friday at 10:45 a.m. ET.

An analyst for ESPN's Sunday Night Baseball, Hall of Fame second baseman Joe Morgan won back-to-back World Series with the Reds. He contributes a weekly column to

 More from ESPN...
Sammy prepared to be disciplined over corked bat
Now baseball officials have ...

Seventy-six Sosa bats found to be clean
An embarrassed Sammy Sosa ...

Grace uncorks some humor at Sosa's expense
Mark Grace brought his own ...

Dan Patrick: Controversy Uncorked
A suspicious eye is now cast ...

Stark: Shattered image?
Thanks to the video age, ...

Ratto: The big screw-up
The Home Run Derby will never ...

Morgan: Use QuesTec for training, not grading
QuesTec should be used as a ...

Joe Morgan Archive

 In His Own Words
Sammy Sosa looks to clear his name of any wrongdoing.
Standard | Cable Modem

 Part of the Game?
Sosa's peers respond to the controversy.
Standard | Cable Modem

 ESPN Tools
Email story
Most sent
Print story
Daily email