![]() |
![]()
|
| Monday, May 5 Updated: May 6, 2:16 PM ET As home runs rise, stolen bases fall By Rob Neyer ESPN.com |
||||||||||||||
I think the idea of risk/reward is what we deal with in our society. To risk an out, and your reward is only a base, I think is not quite what we want to do. It's not good economics of baseball. It's often said that if a baseball fan from 100 years ago were somehow transported to our time, he would recognize baseball as essentially the same game he loved in the early days of the 20th century. But while baseball remains the same game with virtually the same rules, the way the game is played has certainly changed. Consider:
These things -- home runs and stolen bases -- are not completely unrelated, for one oft-mentioned reason and one less-mentioned reason. The oft-mentioned reason is that cited by Bobby Valentine: The greater the chance of the baserunner scoring on a subsequent home run, the less sense it makes for that baserunner to risk removing himself from the inning with an unsuccessful steal attempt. The less-mentioned reason is that few players can both hit many home runs and steal many bases. And when there's a premium put on home runs, it's easier for the home-run hitter to find a place in the lineup. A detailed analysis might allow us to quantify these causes (and perhaps identify others), but in the meantime a stroll down memory lane, National League-style, is instructive. Early in the 20th century, the home run was a rare event, and the steal was not. The aforementioned 1902 season saw an abnormally low number of home runs -- only 96 in 564 games -- but the other seasons in that era weren't exactly power-packed either. In 1903, National Leaguers hit 151 home runs ... and stole 1,562 bases. That is, for every home run hit, 10.3 bases were stolen. That ratio went up and down over the next few years, but didn't change significantly until 1911, when a new cork-centered baseball led to significant increases in hitting in both leagues. Yet while homers in the National League went up significantly, steals also went up, to their highest level (2.7 per game) since 1903 (2.8 per game). In 1911, no National League club stole fewer than 148 bases, and the New York Giants set a still-standing post-1900 major-league record with 347 steals. In that first season of the livelier baseball, National Leaguers hit 316 home runs, a figure that wouldn't be reached again until 1921. But though nearly a decade passed without the NL topping those 316 homers, steals decreased anyway. In 1913, roughly 2.5 bases were swiped per game, but from 1915 through 1919 the figure was closer to two steals per game, with no apparent connection to home runs. That changed in 1920, though. NL hitters finished that season with 261 homers, a 14-percent increase (on a per-game basis) over 1919. More dramatically, steals per game dropped 25 percent, with the league stealing fewer than 1,000 bases (969) for the first time ever. And from there, it was a heyday for power hitters and the end of an era for base-stealers. In 1921, National Leaguers hit 460 home runs (easily a new high) and stole only 803 bases (easily a new low). In 1926, even though home runs were down from the previous season, for the first time the NL averaged less than one steal per game. How dramatic was this change? Just seven seasons earlier, NL games averaged more than two steals per game. For the next four decades, home-run totals went up and down, but steals just stayed down. In every season from 1930 through 1969, NL games averaged less than one stolen base per game. Every season. Another way to approach this issue is to look at the ratio of steals to homers. In 1927, just as in every previous National League season, there were more steals (649) than home runs (483). In 1928, however, the hitters (610) finally passed the runners (568). And it would be nearly 50 years before the runners went back ahead. In 1976, though, National Leaguers stole 1,369 bases and hit 1,113 home runs. As it turned out, that was something of a down year for homers, but from 1978 through 1991 there were more steals than homers in every season. And in 1986 and '87, even as home-run totals were exploding, National Leaguers stole more bases per game (1.9 in both seasons) than they'd swiped since 1919. It was an exciting brand of baseball, played almost as if nobody had quite figured out what was happening. Unfortunately, it didn't last. Since hitting that high-water mark, steal numbers have dropped steadily (if not uniformly) to the point where in each of the last two seasons, we've seen approximately one stolen base per game. And yes, we can probably blame the home runs. While there's not a perfect correlation between more power and less running, the evidence is pretty compelling: When homers go up, steals go down. It's not a coincidence that in 1930, the National League set league records for most home runs (892) and fewest steals (481). It's not a coincidence that in 1953, the National League set records for most home runs (1,197) and fewest steals (342). Does stealing fewer bases -- or more precisely, attempting to steal fewer bases -- make for smarter baseball, as Bobby Valentine argues? Sure it does. Do fewer stolen bases make for better baseball? Of course not. Variety is the spice of life. Just as a bird-watcher wants to see as many species as he can and a movie-lover wants to see as many different sorts of movies as she can, a baseball fan is rewarded by various styles of play. But lest we rue the days that cork-centered baseballs and free weights were born, it's worth noting that today's variety suffers only by comparison with the baseball of the 1970s and '80s. Though stolen-base totals have today reached their lowest level since the 1970s, they remain higher -- and for the most part, significantly higher -- than they were from the late 1930s through the 1960s. (This is, by the way, another piece of the argument for the 1980s as the true Golden Age of Baseball.) So yes, it would be great to see a more exciting style of play, especially on the basepaths. But let's be thankful for what we do have. Because it could be a lot worse. Senior writer Rob Neyer writes four columns per week during the baseball season. His new book, "Rob Neyer's Big Book of Baseball Lineups," has just been published by Fireside. For more information, visit Rob's Web site. |
| |||||||||||||