Pitching Probables
Injuries: AL | NL
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
Message Board

Playoff Schedule
News Wire
Daily Glance
Power Alley
MLB Insider

Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
ESPN Auctions
Thursday, July 3
Updated: July 4, 7:43 PM ET
Willis, Jones sit on NL All-Star fence

By Phil Rogers
Special to

Andruw Jones is one of the most talented players in the majors. He's having another excellent season, with plenty of statistical reinforcement behind his effort. Preston Wilson has already driven in 70 runs.

Yet both are in serious danger of winding up on the cutting room floor when Dusty Baker makes the final call on the National League roster for the upcoming All-Star team.

Along with rookie lefty Dontrelle Willis and recently disabled 11-game winner Shawn Chacon, to name just a couple, Jones and Wilson might not fit on the final 32-man roster, which will be unveiled on Sunday.

The NL All-Stars
Note: Phil Rogers' projections factor in the impact of injuries, fan voting and the rule requiring each team to have one player on the team

C: Javy Lopez, Braves
1B: Todd Helton, Rockies
2B: Marcus Giles, Braves
SS: Edgar Renteria, Cardinals
3B: Scott Rolen, Cardinals
OF: Gary Sheffield, Braves
OF: Barry Bonds, Giants
OF: Sammy Sosa, Cubs

Infielders (5)
Alex Gonzalez, Marlins
Jeff Kent, Astros
Mike Lowell, Marlins
Jim Thome, Phillies
Jose Vidro, Expos

Outfielders (5)
Jim Edmonds, Cardinals
Brian Giles, Pirates
Luis Gonzalez, Diamondbacks
Geoff Jenkins, Brewers
Albert Pujols, Cardinals

Catchers (2)
Jason LaRue, Reds
Benito Santiago, Giants

Pitchers (12)
Armando Benitez, Mets
Kevin Brown, Dodgers
Eric Gagne, Dodgers
Hideo Nomo, Dodgers
Jake Peavy, Padres
Mark Prior, Cubs
Jason Schmidt, Giants
John Smoltz, Braves
Billy Wagner, Astros
Woody Williams, Cardinals
Randy Wolf, Phillies
Kerry Wood, Cubs

Like Anaheim manager Mike Scioscia, Baker must react to the results of the new, three-tiered selection process, which gives players a direct say in the naming of 16 NL All-Stars. He'll be in a huge bind if the players do a poor job.

It will already be impossible for him to take the best team possible as he must find a semi-qualified representative of four teams (Cincinnati, the Mets, Pittsburgh and San Diego) that do not have anybody with commanding presence.

Baker also must make adjustments because it appears the fan vote will send Sammy Sosa to U.S. Cellular Field despite his least productive first half since 1992.

The vote totals released Tuesday also showed Atlanta's Marcus Giles ahead of Jeff Kent at second base. That could provide a complication as Giles does not have as compelling of an All-Star case as Kent or Montreal's Jose Vidro.

The selection riddle would grow even wilder if Jeff Bagwell or Rafael Furcal -- heaven forbid both -- were to rally from smallish deficits to secure starting berths. Both are having decent seasons, but neither qualifies among the top three at his position.

Assuming the fan vote remains the same and that there are no unseen complications from the players' vote -- which there easily could be -- the outfield will be the biggest dilemma for Baker. Some believe the Cubs' Corey Patterson is an attractive candidate, but it's impossible to see how he can squeeze in.

Barry Bonds and Gary Sheffield are deserving of the support they've received from fans. Sosa would be there on reputation alone, however.

With that as the starting outfield, the best reserve choices are Albert Pujols (.379-23-72), Luis Gonzalez (.318-17-60), Jones (.286-20-57), Wilson (.301-18-73) and the surging Geoff Jenkins (.283-19-61).

Jones is not only a productive hitter, but also a perennial Gold Glover. Like Wilson, he should be on the team. But they figure to be the first guys bumped for a combination of reasons.

Pujols, who will almost certainly be Baker's choice as the starting designated hitter, is an automatic pick. Jenkins stays on because he's the lone Brewer and Gonzalez likewise as the only Diamondback.

All four teams who will need to have players forced onto the roster have candidates in the outfield: Chicago native Cliff Floyd (Mets), Brian Giles and Kenny Lofton (Pittsburgh), Rondell White (San Diego) and Austin Kearns (Cincinnati).

Giles, who lost time to injury this season, looks like the best choice among that group. The guess here is that 22-year-old right-hander Jake Peavy will represent the Padres with closer Armando Benitez going from the Mets and catcher Jason LaRue representing the Reds.

If Peavy and Benitez are forced onto the pitching staff, a couple deserving pitchers will stay home. One of those could be Florida's Willis, the ex-Cubs farmhand who has begun his career by going 8-1 with a 2.13 ERA over his first 71 2/3 big-league innings.

He'd be a fun guy to watch, but don't count on him surviving the cut. This is abstract art that could get even stranger before the picture is completed.

Phil Rogers is the national baseball writer for the Chicago Tribune, which has a Web site at

 More from ESPN...
Stark: An All-Star frenzy
A pitching matchup of young ...
Vote: Who should be NL reserves?
SportsNation: Pick who you ...

Rogers: AL All-Stars
From Melvin Mora to Eric ...

Neyer: Mora a definite somebody
Melvin Mora joins the short ...

Kreidler: Baseball's All-Star gamble
Bud Selig's fatal mistake was ...

Phil Rogers Archive

 ESPN Tools
Email story
Most sent
Print story
Daily email