Rumblings and Grumblings

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Power Alley
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Joe Morgan
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Friday, January 11
Updated: April 17, 5:52 PM ET
 
Ballot issues: Less time, more consistency

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

Ozzie Smith was one of the lucky ones.

He only had to go through one Hall of Fame election to collect his invitation to the annual, midsummer Cooperstown Celebrity Golf Tournament and Tearful Induction Ceremony.

He has no idea what a fortunate man he is. He ought to ask Gary Carter, who now has gone through five of these elections, is still waiting and had to watch his wife bust out in tears this week when they learned he'd fallen 11 votes short.

“ I saw Andre Dawson. And let me tell you something. There were only two players in my lifetime whose teammates held them in awe. One was Mickey Mantle. The other was Andre Dawson. If you were around, if you saw them play, you know that. But the numbers don't tell you that. ”
— Jerome Holtzman

Or ask Tony Perez, who had to watch the last RBI of his career fade 14 years deep in the rear-view mirror -- and suffer through nine elections -- before he finally made it.

Or ask, say, Jim Kaat, who has survived 14 elections without a ticket to Cooperstown and still has to endure one more -- 36 years after his first 20-win season.

"To somebody like me, it isn't cruel and unsual punishment ... because I don't really consider myself a Hall of Famer," said Kaat, who has spent the last decade bouncing between 91 votes and 139. "But in a case like Gary Carter's, it is.

"I really feel bad for guys like him. I remember seeing Gary (before) his first year on the ballot, and he was going to sit by the phone that day. I didn't have the heart to tell him, 'Don't waste your time.' Now, he's waited five years, and he's still not in. It seems to me that if a guy's a Hall of Famer, he's a Hall of Famer. And after five years, you ought to either put him in or not."

Well, how about that for a concept? Is there any good reason to put some of these men through 15 elections' worth of ballot torture? Go ahead. Think of one. We dare you.

The correct answer is: NOOOOOOO. So if anyone on the Hall of Fame's board of directors is interested, we're now formally launching a campaign to shorten the time a player has to spend on the ballot from 15 years to five. Or eight at the most.

We don't expect anybody to actually listen to us, of course. So we've enlisted the aid of a prestigious campaign director -- baseball's official historian himself, Hall of Fame baseball writer Jerome Holtzman.

"Fifteen years is too long," Holtzman said. "I think it's awful. I think you should lead this movement to reduce it. Make it eight. That's plenty. If a guy isn't a Hall of Famer after eight years, he isn't a Hall of Famer. Either you're a Hall of Famer or you're not."

It ought to be that simple. Shouldn't it? But it sure hasn't worked out that way. So we say: Let's simplify this process and shorten those ballot years. And here's why:

1. Make the voters decide
Our own personal voting philosophy is that your only job as a Hall of Fame voter is to decide one question: Was this player a Hall of Famer, or was he not? If you think he was, you ought to vote for him every year. And if he wasn't, you don't vote for him any year.

You're allowed to change your mind, of course. And we've done that a few times, on players ranging from Ron Santo to Tony Oliva. But it's clear many Hall of Fame voters have an entirely different standard.

Maybe they want an Ozzie Smith to go into the Hall all by himself, so they don't vote for six players they'd voted for the year before. Or a year comes along where there's no obvious first-year candidate and they want somebody to get inducted, so they vote for six players they'd never voted for before.

Something like that must be going on, because there's no other logical explanation for Don Mattingly's vote total plunging from 145 to 96. Or for Steve Garvey's total cliff-diving from 176 to 134. Or for Bert Blyleven to get 18 fewer votes than Kaat last year but then get 15 votes more than Kaat this year.

"I only got 109 votes this year," Kaat said. "So I figured I must have hung a lot of sliders."

If the term on the ballot was cut to five years, or to the Jerome Holtzman-authorized eight, it would make it a lot tougher for writers to waffle or play those selective-voting games. They would have to make a decision on a player's worthiness once and for all. And we always thought that was the whole point of holding an election in the first place.

2. Vote on what you see
It would seem to make sense to have players being voted on by writers who had actually seen them play. But after a player hangs around the ballot a few years, that isn't how it works out.

Take the case of Kaat. He broke into the big leagues in 1959 -- before many of the current voters were even alive. His peak years began 40 years ago, when he was winning 15 to 25 games eight times between 1962 and 1975. He then spent eight more years as a still-useful back-of-the-rotation starter and situational reliever. He wound up with 283 wins.

He then had to wait the mandatory five years before he even could appear on the ballot. Now it's 14 elections later, and his best years were more than a quarter of a century ago. So many voters evaluating him now have no firsthand impressions to go on. And that makes no sense.

"Look at Goose Gossage," Holtzman said. "I consider myself an expert on relief pitchers. And until (Dennis) Eckersley came along, I considered Goose Gossage the greatest relief pitcher of all time. But the people who saw Goose Gossage pitch -- where are they? They're not the ones voting.

"As time goes on, all you have to rely on is numbers. You either forget the guy himself, or you didn't even know the guy himself. And those firsthand impressions, what you saw when you saw the guy himself, are very important. You shouldn't just rely on numbers. But that's what's happening, and that's a big problem."

3. Eliminate the numbers inflation
Speaking of numbers, they aren't what they used to be. You may have noticed that. But the more today's voters have to rely on numbers to evaluate yesterday's players, the more they tend to forget that a 30-save season or a 30-homer season in 1983 had a completely different meaning than a 30-save season or 30-homer season in 2001.

So the numbers of a Gossage or a Bruce Sutter, of a Dale Murphy or an Andre Dawson, don't look as impressive through the prism of today's bloated stats as they looked in real life at the time. And it's obvious that's a factor in the voting.

"I saw Andre Dawson," Holtzman said. "And let me tell you something. There were only two players in my lifetime whose teammates held them in awe. One was Mickey Mantle. The other was Andre Dawson. If you were around, if you saw them play, you know that. But the numbers don't tell you that."

Here at Rumblings and Grumblings, we love numbers, possibly even more than we love ice cream. But numbers just illuminate the game. They are not the game itself.

So numbers have their place, but they shouldn't take the place of firsthand observation. And the shorter the period of time a player spends on the ballot, the more likely it is his career was actually witnessed by the people voting on him.

"Why do players have to wait five years to appear on the ballot?" Kaat wondered. "If you want to wait two years after the guy's career is over to let a little time elapse, fine. Wait two years. Now give him five years on the ballot and let guys who saw him play decide whether he's a Hall of Famer or not. And if he's not in by then, he's off."

Hey, why not? Last summer, the Hall of Fame board got so exasperated with the Veterans Committee that it totally revamped that whole voting process. So the board should turn its attention now to the main voting process.

It's a process that works great now -- as long as you're Ozzie Smith or George Brett. But if you're Gary Carter or Jim Kaat or Luis Tiant, it's not working so hot.

So if baseball really wants to contract, we've found something that deserves to be contracted much more than the Twins -- those 15 years on the ballot. Contract that.

Miscellaneous Rumblings

  • Looks as if the Phillies are finally going to make a significant addition. They're closing in on a one-year deal, believed to be heavily incentive-laden, with Terry Adams, who would loom as a No. 3 starter.

    Of the 16 teams that finished with a winning record last year, the Phillies and Twins are the only two that haven't added a major-league player from outside the organization this winter. And let's just say the Twins have been distracted by other issues.

    The Phillies, in fairness, did spend much of December working on potential Scott Rolen deals. And they were the runners-up in the Aaron Sele bidding.

    But at a time when they were positioned to make a serious run in the NL East and needed an active winter to reawaken their fan base, their inability to get more accomplished isn't playing well in an already-skeptical city.

  • According to an official from one club that had initial interest in Juan Gonzalez after hearing reports that agent Jeff Moorad had insured Gonzalez's back condition, that policy "wasn't quite as advertised."

    The policy actually excluded Gonzalez's back from coverage unless the club signing him wanted to buy out that exclusion for an additional hefty premium. And even then, rather than insure the entire contract if Gonzalez went down with a back problem, the maximum his team could collect was $5 million.

  • With Gonzalez's signing, the Rangers have now committed $107.5 million on their five major free-agent signings this winter (Gonzalez, Chan Ho Park, Dave Burba, Jay Powell, Todd Van Poppel). That doesn't even count their free agents on minor-league contracts -- Bill Pulsipher, Hideki Irabu, Anthony Telford, Jeremi Gonzalez and Jason Maxwell. They've also traded for John Rocker, Carl Everett and Herbert Perry. Last year, thanks to Alex Rodriguez, they committed another $267 million to seven free agents.

    So the cost to Tom Hicks of keeping that Transactions column in business these last two winters has come to a hair under $375 million. Which would buy a whole lot of fajitas at Joe T. Garcia's.

  • One interesting story to watch this spring, in the wake of all the Mets' moves, is what they do with Todd Zeile. They still owe him $6 million. The Mo Vaughn deal and the shift of Edgardo Alfonzo to third leave Zeile with no position to play. And he's coming off surgery to remove chips from his elbow, so even if they wanted to trade him before spring training, that's now impossible.

    At least three teams figure to be interested if the Mets either release him (doubtful) or eat most of the contract in a deal for a prospect: the Angels, Astros and Rockies.

  • Another player who might turn out to be available come spring training is Astros starter Shane Reynolds. The Astros are loaded with young pitching and might be tempted to fill in multiple missing pieces if the right offer for Reynolds came along.

  • The Braves have given new meaning to the concept of signing "name" free agents this winter. They've signed Julio Franco and Matt Franco. And they've signed Albie Lopez and Javy Lopez.

    They already had Chipper and Andruw Jones on board. So if they're interested in continuing this approach, James and Lyle Mouton are still available to revive their fabled Mouton's Futons act. However, the Red Sox beat them to both Johnny Damon and Damon Buford.

  • After the Braves signed Vinny Castilla, the first reaction of some skeptics was to wonder if Castilla was a good match for the pitcher's-park dimensions of Turner Field. Well, as one NL scout observes, Castilla's revival in Houston last year was not an Enron Field phenomenon.

    Castilla at Enron: .230, 10 HR, 36 RBI in 222 AB
    Castilla (as an Astro) on the road: .309, 13 HR, 46 RBI in 223 AB

  • Another free agent whose home-road numbers aren't what you might think is Rick Helling.

    Helling in Texas, the Coors Field of the AL: 9-2, 3.78, 13 HR in 116 IP
    Helling on the road last year: 3-9, 6.82, 25 HR in 99 IP

  • It's time for the annual rundown of Pete Rose's write-in Hall of Fame vote total. Rose got 18 votes this year -- his most in five years. But since he got 41 votes in what would have been his first year on the ballot, in 1991, he's fluctuated between 15 and 20 every year.

    His year-by-year totals: 41, 15, 19, 20, 19, 20, 12, 16, 17, 15 and 18.

  • The best Hall of Fame story of the year comes from Jack Lang, long-time secretary-treasurer of the Baseball Writers Association, who reports that Ozzie Smith actually got one vote this year from beyond the grave.

    That vote came from the late Bob Stevens, the great San Francisco Chronicle baseball writer and Hall of Famer who passed away Jan. 2.

    Lang said Stevens once asked if he could include, in his will, a list of players he would have voted for for the Hall of Fame after he died. Lang said that wasn't allowed, but Stevens managed the next-best thing:

    He cast his ballot this year several weeks before his death. So since it wasn't counted until this week, he did in fact achieve his goal of continuing to vote for the Hall of Fame after he'd passed away. Do you believe in reinductionation?

    Triviality
    Which shortstop (still active) won the 1993 Gold Glove award that finally ended Ozzie Smith's streak of 13 consecutive Gold Gloves? (Answer at bottom.)

    Useless Information Dept.

  • There may be some astrologers out there who can explain why so many players had dramatic Hall of Fame vote fluctuations this year, but we can't. So we'll stick with presenting the men with the biggest ups and downs. (Since 43 fewer writers voted this year than last, we'll do it by percentage).

    Biggest increases: Gary Carter (up 8 percent), Luis Tiant (up 6 percent), Bert Blyleven (up 3 percent).

    Biggest swan dives: Don Mattingly (down 8 percent), Steve Garvey (down 6 percent), Jim Kaat (down 4 percent), Dale Murphy and Jim Rice (down 3 percent).

  • One thing we can safely forecast: Gary Carter will be going into the Hall of Fame someday. Carter was the 10th player to come within 11 votes of election or closer before reaching his final year on the ballot. He might be relieved to know that all of the previous nine were elected the next year.

    Those nine and the margin they missed by:

    Don Sutton (9) in 1997
    Billy Williams (4) in 1986
    Robin Roberts (9) in 1975
    Roy Campanella (8) in 1968
    Joe Medwick (7) in 1967
    Bill Terry (7) in 1953
    Paul Waner (8) in 1951
    Pie Traynor (2) in 1947
    Frank Chance (7) in 1945

    Three other players -- Nellie Fox, Jim Bunning and Orlando Cepeda -- missed by seven votes or fewer in their final year on the ballot. And all three were elected by the Veterans Committee.

  • So if Carter does make it, the really fascinating question is whether he'll go into the Hall wearing an Expos cap -- because by the time he's inducted, the Expos stand a stupendous chance of having ceased to exist (either via contraction or moving vans).

    According to the Hall of Fame's Bill Francis, no player has ever been chiseled onto a Hall of Fame plaque wearing the cap of a team that was no longer in existence (unless you count the Brooklyn Dodgers or New York Giants, who kept their name but changed coasts).

    That means no St. Louis Browns (nope, not even Denny Galehouse). No Seattle Pilots (not even Steve Hovley). And no Cleveland Spiders (not even Cupid Childs).

  • Even Smith himself was astounded by the fact he got 91.7 percent of the vote. Only four infielders in history have ever attracted a higher percentage than that:

    George Brett, 98.2
    Mike Schmidt, 96.7
    Honus Wagner, 95.1
    Brooks Robinson 92.0

    The only other infielder to top 90 percent: Rod Carew (90.5).

  • When you hear people tell you other shortstops had more range than Ozzie, you're officially cleared to chuckle. The Wizard's 621-assist season in 1980 says it all. It's the only 600-assist season by any shortstop since 1924. And in the 21 seasons since, only once has a shortstop even gotten to within 50 of that -- Cal Ripken (583, in 1984).

    Smith also had eight seasons of 500 assists or more. Since he retired, all of the other shortstops in the big leagues have combined for six seasons of 500-plus: two by Neifi Perez, one apiece by Orlando Cabrera, Mike Bordick, Alex Gonzalez (Toronto edition) and Miguel Tejada.

  • Finally, Smith was also a three-time member of the prestigious 40-0 Club (40 or more stolen bases in a season, zero home runs). The only other players in history who can make that claim:

    Maury Wills (four times -- including three seasons of 50-zero), Otis Nixon (four) and Eddie Collins (three).

    Most stolen bases by a zero-homer man this year: 31, by Tampa Bay's Jason Tyner (who actually stole 42 without a trot, if you count his six weeks in triple-A).

  • Our favorite baseball toy of the offseason is the new Sabermetric Encyclopedia CD-rom just published by one of our loyal readers, Lee Sinins. That 40-0 Club was just one of the many fun computations we've manufactured with this encyclopedia, which is available at www.baseball-encyclopedia.com.

    Here come some others, beginning with the 10 hitters who have made the most outs over the last 10 years:

    1. Marquis Grissom, 4441
    2. Rafael Palmeiro, 4314
    3. Craig Biggio, 4277
    4. Steve Finley, 4261
    5. Eric Karros, 4248
    6. Jay Bell, 4227
    7. Omar Vizquel, 4211
    8. Chuck Knoblauch, 4162
    9. Brady Anderson, 4141
    10. Sammy Sosa, 4129

  • We could have guessed that Barry Bonds had been issued more intentional walks than any player in baseball over the last 10 seasons. But now we know he had almost twice as many as any other player. The leaders:

    1. Barry Bonds, 274
    2. Ken Griffey Jr., 152
    3. Frank Thomas, 140
    4. Mo Vaughn, 134
    5. Jeff Bagwell, 132
    6. John Olerud, 123
    7. Mark McGwire, 121
    8. Robin Ventura, 113
    T9. Sammy Sosa, 112
    T9. Mike Piazza, 112

    One question: Who had Robin Ventura ahead of Sosa and Piazza in this pool?

  • How about this vital list -- of pitchers who have committed the most balks over the last 10 years:

    1. Brian Anderson, 21
    2. Hideo Nomo, 17
    T3. Darryl Kile, 15
    T3. Kenny Rogers, 15
    T3. Armando Reynoso, 15
    T6. Ismael Valdes, 14
    T6. Pedro Astacio, 14
    T8. Bud Black, 13
    T8. Randy Johnson, 13
    T8. Omar Daal, 13

  • And here's a huge race (literally) to watch this year -- Jeff D'Amico attempting to take over the all-time lead for most career wins by pitchers weighing 250 pounds or more, while C.C. Sabathia tries to catch him:
    PITCHER                 WINS  WEIGHT
    T1. Garland Buckeye      29     260   
    T1. Jeff D'Amico         29     250   
    3.  Jumbo Brown          19     295   
    T4. C.C. Sabathia        17     260   
    T4. Rocky Coppinger      17     250   
    6.  Johnny Hutchings     12     250   
    7.  Steve Rain            3     250   
    T8. Carlos Zambrano       1     250   
    T8. Chad Paronto          1     255   
    T8. Willie Smith          1     250   
    T8. Chuck Malone          1     250

    Sorry, we have to go by official, Baseball Encyclopedia-listed weights here. So don't go sending in any Where's David Wells complaints.

    Trivia Answer
    Jay Bell, then with the Pirates.

    Jayson Stark is a senior writer for ESPN.com.







  •  More from ESPN...
    Stark: Tough calls for the Hall
    Jayson Stark agonized over ...
    Ozzie elected to baseball's Hall on first ballot
    Ozzie Smith was elected ...

    Jayson Stark Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story