Jayson Stark

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Power Alley
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Joe Morgan
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Thursday, January 17
 
Relocation? It's about time

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

PHOENIX -- The first item on our post-owners-meeting agenda involves the third incarnation of the Washington Senators -- or someone like them.

Let's just say that Bud Selig let a very large cat out of a tightly knotted bag Thursday with three simple words:

"Relocation is coming."

For months, for years, any time the commish found one of those pesky relocation questions hurtling at him, he lurched out of the way like a hitter dodging a Randy Johnson brushback pitch.

In fact, wasn't it just November that Selig was still dismissing the idea of allowing franchises to move by saying firmly that all relocation would accomplish was to "move the same set of problems from one market to another?"

But then, suddenly, on Thursday, that stance abruptly shifted course by a mere 180 degrees. Do not adjust your compasses. Just follow along here.

It came when Washington Post reporter Steve Fainaru followed up on an earlier Selig remark that all of this frenzied owner activity this winter should be viewed as part of a "bigger picture" -- by asking whether that bigger picture includes relocation.

The commissioner then casually replied: "No doubt relocation is coming. It's just a question of when."

Later, he made it clear that "when" would not be 2002. But he did not rule out 2003. And you can feel free to read as much into that as you wish.

Our first reaction to this new position was simple: Hey, it's about time.

Baseball should have allowed the Expos to move years ago, once it was clear Montreal was never going to care about baseball or build a new ballpark that might have at least sparked a little renewed curiosity about baseball.

A few bucks in Peter Angelos' pocket -- enough to convince him to drop the Orioles' opposition to a team in D.C. or Northern Virginia -- was always a much cheaper, and much better, option than contraction. And the Expos aren't the only team that ought to be allowed to move.

The A's should be allowed to relocate to the Silicon Valley. The Marlins or Devil Rays ought to move to Orlando. This sport needs that flexibility to fix its problems. Revenue sharing alone won't do it. Passion and geography ought to be part of the formula.

But the other reaction to Selig's remarks Thursday was a basic question that swept through baseball: Why this change of heart?

Selig hinted that he'd always seen franchise relocation as an option once his sport had a new, improved labor deal. But some Selig watchers have a different take.

One theory that had been making the rounds lately, even before Thursday, was this: The power brokers in the game weren't necessarily opposed to the Expos moving to Washington. They just didn't want Jeffrey Loria to move to Washington.

So ask yourself this: What has happened between Selig's anti-relocation stance in November and his pro-relocation position of mid-January? By remarkable coincidence, Loria is now all but approved as the new owner of the Marlins, and MLB will operate the Expos.

Now, if contraction doesn't happen, MLB can turn around and sell the Expos to a Washington-area buyer and make a fine little profit on the $120 million price it paid Loria for the club.

Or if contraction does happen, MLB can use the threat of a move to Washington -- or elsewhere -- to get new stadiums built in communities that have long resisted them. Relocation always has made for great leverage throughout modern baseball history. And after Selig's relocation U-turn Thursday, it has finally regained its position as the leverage champion of the world.

Item Two: Mr. Fehr visits the owners
Remember this: When players' union chief Donald Fehr walked out of the ballroom Thursday after his historic appearance at an official meeting of his favorite owners, a new labor deal was no closer than it was when Fehr entered that room three hours earlier.

As one man present in that ballroom observed later, "This isn't how deals get done. Deals aren't made with 50 people in a room. Deals get made with four people in a room."

But as accurate as that analysis may be, there were three big reasons Fehr's visit to these meetings represented the commissioner's most inspired idea of this entire offseason:

  • 1. It was an oasis of civility in a relationship that has done nothing but grow more strained and heated all winter.

  • 2. It allowed Fehr to remind these owners that the players don't want a work stoppage any more than most owners do, and that somewhere out there is a deal that won't necessarily "make everybody ecstatic" but can at least be "acceptable" to both sides.

  • 3. It was an opportunity for owners to remember that Fehr, Gene Orza and the players who accompanied the union leaders to this meeting are human beings -- just as it gave Fehr a chance to look into the eyes of John Henry and Kevin McClatchey and a room full of owners he'd never spoken with in his life.

    "One of the interesting things about baseball is that I don't know many individual owners very well," Fehr said. "And they don't know me. They know players. They know agents. But they don't know me. And the better we know one another, that's always a positive thing."

    Not even George Bush and Tom Daschle can snipe at each other from a distance better than these two sides. But now, in back-to-back weeks, Selig has addressed a bargaining session filled with players, and Fehr has spoken to a ballroom full of owners. And at the very least, that encourages the spirit of well-mannered dialogue.

    "I know what Don hears from players, and last week, he wanted me to hear those things and respond," Selig said. "And I know what I hear from owners, and today, I wanted him to hear those things and respond. . . . What I heard (from Fehr) today, I'd heard before. But most of the people in the room hadn't heard it before. And I think that's a good thing."

    How good a thing? "Only time will tell," Selig said. "We'll have to see over time," Fehr said.

    One Q-and-A session in a big hotel won't make the big issues any easier to address and solve. And Fehr pointedly reminded the owners of that Thursday by saying, when the subject of a luxury tax came up, that "players aren't luxuries."

    But the more efforts are made to keep the conversations civil and adult-like, and the quieter and less publicized those conversations are, the easier it will be to tell if these two sides are even trying to make a deal.

    As the last strike proved, public negotiations are nothing more than spin-doctoring showtime. Private, behind-the-scene negotiations tend to be the real deal.

    So just listen for the noise and rhetoric as these negotiations get going. The more you hear about them, the more worried you ought to be.

    Jayson Stark is a senior writer for ESPN.com.







  •  More from ESPN...
    Stark: Owner shifting leads to confusion
    Ownership changes have ...
    Jayson Stark Archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story