Spring Training

Jayson Stark

Keyword
MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Transactions
Injuries
Players
Free Agents
Offseason Moves
All-Time Stats
Message Board
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
CLUBHOUSE


THE ROSTER
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
Jayson Stark
Jim Caple
John Sickels
SHOP@ESPN.COM
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Tuesday, March 5
 
Flycatchers: Jones tops Hunter as No. 1

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. -- Bobby Cox sat in the visitor's dugout, stroking his chin. He had just been asked to name the best play he'd ever seen by the best center fielder alive, Andruw Jones.

Cox thought about it. And thought about it. And thought about it. Finally, he realized this was a question that had no answer.

Andruw Jones
Andruw Jones has won a Gold Glove the past four seasons.

"There have been so many," the Braves' manager said of his center fielder. "We remember Otis Nixon for one play (climbing the center-field wall in the early '90s). Andruw makes one like that every day."

If the standard for greatness in a center fielder is the number of balls that look like doubles off the bat that turn into outs when Jones' glove gets in the way, then this is a center fielder with almost no peers. It's sacrilegious to mention any active center fielder in the same breath as Willie Mays. But baseball people often do when they talk about Jones.

Oh, Junior Griffey and Jim Edmonds have had their freeze-frame moments. Torii Hunter and Mike Cameron can be downright breathtaking. But when we polled a bunch of scouts this spring to determine the five best active defensive center fielders, there was Andruw Jones -- and then there was everybody else.

"Andruw constantly catches balls I never think he'll get to," Cox said. "It happens on a nightly basis. He runs them down, and he does it easy. He's got the ability to play shallow and go back. And he's not afraid of anything -- the ground or the wall. He's just always amazing me."

Hunter narrowly outpolled Cameron for the best in the American League. Here's the entire crew that made it into the best-in-the-big-leagues argument:

1. Andruw Jones, Braves
What, you were expecting maybe Jose Canseco? Everybody we surveyed picked Jones as the best. Among the reviews:

By the numbers
Clay Davenport of Baseball Prospectus has devised a method to evaluate individual defensive ability, arriving at a total runs gained or lost compared to an average defender at the position. Here are the top five defensive center fielders from the Baseball Prospectus 2002:

1. Torii Hunter, +23
2. Andruw Jones, +18
3. Doug Glanvile, +16
4. Carlos Beltran, +14
5. Mike Cameron, +11

  • "He's in his own world. He just does stuff other guys can't do and does it easy. He gets to so many balls you think will be hits -- and catches them like they're routine. I don't think there's another center fielder in the big leagues in his league."

  • "You watch the Braves outfielders, and the left fielder and right fielder just take balls from where they are to the line. Andruw takes everything else."

  • "Anybody who makes the game look so boring, you know he's a great player."

    2. Torii Hunter, Twins
    What does it tell you that Hunter played 14 fewer games than Andruw Jones last year -- but ran down almost exactly the same number of fly balls (460 putouts for Hunter, 461 for Jones)? It tells you he is the American League's human highlight film in center.

    Scouting report: "Defensively, he has no peers in that league. He gets as quick a read off the bat as anybody I've ever seen. It's bang-bang -- contact, then he's started. And he's always in the right place. He doesn't have great pure speed. But he looks like he does because he has such great instincts."

    3. Mike Cameron, Mariners
    Second in the AL only to Hunter in total chances by center fielders last year, Cameron is so good he has practically made those latte drinkers in Seattle throw away their Junior Griffey highlight tapes.

    Scouting report: "Plays in a big ballpark and covers a lot of ground. He closes the gaps well. But one thing that stands out to me is that he's very comfortable around the fence. He plays the way Griffey used to play until someone told him he had more value in the field than on the bench."

    4. Jim Edmonds, Cardinals
    He looks great on Web Gems, but Edmonds was actually a source of great debate among our panelists. Here's why:

    Scouting report: "He's got great hands and a plus throwing arm. He throws very well on the run. My problem with him is, he dresses up the plays he makes a little bit. He makes those catches that get him in the highlight films, but he's diving when guys like Andruw Jones are just gliding under the ball. I can think of three or four guys who make all the plays he makes without all the extras."

    There were several similar comments -- but everybody mentioned Edmonds when contemplating this list. And with four Gold Gloves in five years, he was hard to leave off.

    5. Doug Glanville, Phillies
    OK, name the two National League center fielders with 400 putouts last year? Andruw Jones and . . .

    Nope. Not Edmonds. Not Steve Finley. It was Glanville, a man who rolled up almost 100 more total chances than Edmonds and had nobody (other than Jones) within 50 of him in the National League.

    Scouting report: "There's a guy who gets virtually no consideration for the Gold Glove but should. ... Plays under control. Very steady. Average arm but very accurate. Has all the intangibles."

    Just missed
    Carlos Beltran, Steve Finley.

    Would have been there
    If Griffey had just stayed healthy, he'd have been right near the top of this list. But as one scout put it, "he's been hurt so much the last couple of years, he's dropped because he hasn't played. But even watching him play hurt last year, you could see he still has it in him."

    Most overrated
    Bernie Williams.

    Wave of the future
    Juan Pierre, Corey Patterson.

    Jayson Stark is a senior writer for ESPN.com.








  •  More from ESPN...
    Spring Training coverage

    Jayson Stark archive

     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story