Rumblings and Grumblings

MLB
Scores
Schedule
Pitching Probables
Standings
Statistics
Players
Transactions
Injuries: AL | NL
Minor Leagues
MLB en espanol
Message Board
CLUBHOUSE


FEATURES
Playoff Schedule
News Wire
Daily Glance
Power Alley
History
MLB Insider


THE ROSTER
Jim Caple
Peter Gammons
Rob Neyer
John Sickels
Jayson Stark
ESPN MALL
TeamStore
ESPN Auctions
SPORT SECTIONS
Wednesday, June 4
Updated: June 5, 10:17 AM ET
 
Let's allow fans to see how the other half lives

By Jayson Stark
ESPN.com

Here at Rumblings and Grumblings' international headquarters, we occasionally like to think of ourselves as baseball's fix-it crew.

Got a problem no one else can solve? Just call us at 1-800-RUMBLING. We'll get right on it.

Edgar Martinez
Fans in NL cities should see Edgar Martinez as a DH, not just a PH.

So there we were Tuesday in Philadelphia, in the dugout of the Seattle Mariners, when a pesky little Interleague Play Crisis reared its pesky head, with almost no warning.

Seattle manager Bob Melvin was telling the story of how he was writing out his lineup that afternoon for the first interleague road game of the year. Then he arrived at the No. 4 spot in his batting order, the spot where he's pre-programmed to write out the name, "Edgar Martinez," every night of the week.

His hand "kept wanting to write Edgar's name in there," Melvin said. But his brain told him his favorite powers that be probably wouldn't go for that, because the schedule makers had sent him to a National League park. Which meant, alas, he was now sitting in the No-DH-ing section of baseball's dining room.

The rules are the rules, of course. There's no fighting them. There's no changing them. And we can all admit there's a certain logic to the interleague rule that goes: NL rules in NL parks, AL rules in AL parks.

But it's time to make a very important point: Just because it's logical doesn't mean it's sensible.

After all, if you live in a National League city, the Seattle Mariners aren't going to visit your town much more often than Halley's Comet. So suppose you want to take your kids out to see the great Edgar Martinez play. Is it really sensible to have to tell them: "OK, try real hard to stay awake, little Johnny, because Edgar will be pinch-hitting in a couple of hours?"

Heck, no. That isn't sensible. It's deplorable. If you had one shot every six years or so to see the Mariners come to your town, wouldn't you want to see Edgar play?

"Yeah," Martinez chuckled Tuesday night. "I would."

But even though Martinez is clearly the best DH alive, and even though his absence -- in the words of Seattle center fielder Mike Cameron -- "just about blows our whole team up," this doesn't have to be just about him.

Cork Dept. Rumblings
Sosa
It's been tough to find people in baseball, at least early on, who believe that Sammy Sosa didn't know what bat he was using when he picked that cork stick out of the bat rack Tuesday night. But if it turns out that the rest of Sosa's bats are cork-free, at least that would lessen the suspicion that Sosa was cheating when he hit all those 505 home runs.

How many bats are broken these days in every game? How many bats break in an inning when a Mariano Rivera or John Smoltz is out there? So if Sosa had been using a corked bat repeatedly for the last five years, or eight years, or 10 years, wouldn't someone have caught him long before this?

"Sammy knows how common it is for bats to break," said one Sosa sympathizer. "He also knows that bats that have been `worked on' are more prone to exploding. Sammy is a lot of things. But he's not a stupid guy."

That doesn't mean people ought to accept his alibi for this incident without a raised eyebrow. But unlike Albert Belle -- who had a teammate crawl through the ceiling to steal the evidence -- or Wilton Guerrero -- who scrambled around trying to retrieve his cork before the proper authorities did -- at least Sosa's first act was to admit he'd done what he'd done and apologize.

Unlike Belle, who denied everything even after being caught, Sosa seems to understand he needs to accept at least some responsibility. In fact, there has already been some speculation that if his suspension is in line with previous bat-tampering suspensions -- i.e., about a week -- he might not even appeal.

But of course, once people get beyond the question, "Did Sammy cheat?" the next question is: "Is everybody cheating?"

Well, we'd bet that a half-dozen bats break every day in the average major-league game. And no one has been caught corking in seven years. So that tells you the percentage of corkers and cheaters is lower than some people think.

But when Dusty Baker tried to claim Tuesday he'd never heard of anybody corking in all his years in baseball, it ought to qualify him for a spot in the next troupe down at Second City.

Former Indians have suggested in recent years that they actually had a wood shop at the old Cleveland Stadium in the late 1980s and early 1990s. And who doesn't know that cheating by pitchers and hitters is a more time-honored baseball tradition than the seventh-inning stretch?

One player told us recently that bat-corking technology has improved so much in recent years that the holes being bored in the wood can now be as small as 1/16 or 1/8 of an inch -- and still help improve bat speed. And the smaller the holes, the less likely the bat is to break.

But the fact is, not even players themselves know how much cheating is taking place.

"How much that goes on, I don't know, and I don't want to know," said 20-year-veteran reliever Dan Plesac. "I used to look at Mark McGwire, and there was no doubt in my mind his forearms were corked."

"Let's say one year that Barry Bonds can't play a position anymore and he has to go and play in the American League," Martinez theorized. "And say he's going for a big record, like the (Hank Aaron) home run record. And now it's interleague play and they go to a National League park and he can't play. I don't think that's good. I think fans want to see players like that play."

We can argue for two weeks about interleague play, about the DH rule, about which league's rules are better. But forget that for a second. Let's ponder that last sentiment: Fans want to see great players play.

What we have now is an interleague system that's designed to keep an Edgar Martinez from playing -- in front of fans who probably have never seen him and are probably never going to see him. Unless ...

Unless, that is, baseball turns immediately to the Rumblings Crisis Intervention Center, because we can solve this problem with a two-word proposal:

DH Night. (Or its four-word promotional variation, DH And Dog Night, in which fans would get to see Edgar and get a free hot dog out of it.)

Here's the deal: When an American League team visits a National League city during interleague play, one game out of every series ought to be DH Night.

The game would be played with AL rules. The DHs all get to play. And fans get more than a chance to see the Edgar Martinezes and Rafael Palmeiros do what they do. They get a real, up-close-and-personal experience with a whole style of play they have argued about for years but never actually gotten to see.

Then, when the NL teams go to the AL cities, we reverse it: One game in every series is Pitchers Get to Hit Night.

Let those AL fans see for themselves that Mark Prior is probably a better hitter than their starting catcher. Let them see that watching the inimitable hacks of an Al Leiter can represent quality entertainment. Let them experience the double switch and the strategic intricacies of the NL game for a change.

We ask you: Is this brilliant or what?

This idea first started hatching inside Rumblings Headquarters over the winter when Padres GM Kevin Towers suggested to us that all interleague games in NL cities should be played with AL rules, and vice-versa. We're not ready for that yet. But one night a series? It accomplishes the same goal, and it creates one extra interesting night in every series. So Towers says he'd take it.

"I always thought the whole idea of the new stuff we're doing -- the wild card, expanded playoffs, interleague play -- was to create more excitement in the game," Towers said. "So why not try something different? We've already started tinkering with interleague. We started out playing just against one division. Now we're rotating divisions. So now let's do one more thing different."

We wouldn't say we did a national Gallup Poll on this brainstorm this week. But let's just say that in the Mariners' clubhouse, it was a major hit.

"Yeah, man, that's cool," said Cameron. "I like that."

"I want every day to be DH Day," said Bret Boone. "I like it when Edgar is in there with me. But I'll take it."

"If I were running baseball, I'd go for it," said Melvin. "Try to lobby for that right now. I'll hold my lineup."

OK, OK. We're lobbying. We're lobbying. But the big test, we figured, was Martinez himself. He's not too happy about basically joining the witness-protection program for a week. So we weren't sure if one game a series would be enough for him.

"That," he gushed, "is the best idea I've ever heard on this situation. I like it."

He didn't even just like it for selfish reasons, too. He saw the big picture.

"I'm sure the fans in the National League want to see how the American League plays the game," he said. "So that's a great opportunity for fans who want to see a certain player or a different type of game. That way, they can see it one night a series."

Precisely. Towers says the flip-flop-the-rules proposal has come up at general managers' meetings but never went beyond that. Well, it has now. And even Martinez figures it's just a matter of time before an idea this sensational goes from the Rumblings desk to the rule book.

"This is how EVERYTHING starts," Martinez said. "You make a story about it. Then people say, `Hey, that's a good idea.' Next thing you know ..."

Yeah, next thing you know, it disappears into cyberspace, never to be heard of again -- until Bud Selig takes credit for it. But when that happens, just remember where you first read it, where you first heard it and what 1-800 number you ought to call the next time an official Baseball Crisis visits a ballpark near you.

Miscellaneous Rumblings

  • Potential bidders for the Expos in Washington, Northern Virginia and Portland, Ore., are paying close attention to their future club's place in the standings these days. And who can blame them?

    Guerrero
    Guerrero

    Those investors know that if the Expos fall out of the race and their fate for next year remains unresolved, the shopping of Vladimir Guerrero and, potentially, Javier Vazquez and Jose Vidro, will begin. And if those centerpieces are gone when the team finally does get sold and moved, it could affect the price those bidders are willing to pay for the franchise.

    "There's only one thing better than getting a team," said a source with ties to one future Expos destination. "And that's getting a good team."

    But if that team were to arrive minus Guerrero and some of the Expos' other current stars, "doesn't that have to reduce the value of the team?" the source wonders.

    The buzz is that MLB is looking for at least $300 million for the Expos. But if the team that ends up being sold is rebuilding, not contending, "then it's a potentially different story," the source said.

    If baseball really intends to resolve the fate of the Expos by the All-Star break, that means we're now at under six weeks to go -- and counting. But the groups in Washington, Northern Virginia and Portland are still waiting for MLB to schedule its long-pending visit to all three sites. So if you think this has been a messy story so far, just wait a few weeks.

  • Meanwhile, there have been whispers around the Expos that Vladimir Guerrero's back problems are more troublesome than anyone has admitted.

  • Clubs that have spoken with the Cubs say Dusty Baker is more interested in signing Matt Williams than the rest of the front office. The Cubs continue to wait for the Marlins to get ready to deal Mike Lowell. There are other teams interested in Lowell, but the Cubs and Marlins both seem to think they match up well in a potential deal.

  • The Red Sox continue to talk as if they expect to make more deals for pitching. But with Shea Hillenbrand gone, the question other clubs are asking is: What do they have left to give up for what they need?

    One scout who watched their Triple-A team in Pawtucket last month said, frankly: "I didn't see anything of quality -- except (left-handed Rule 5 reliever) Matt White. Hector Almonte has great velocity, but he's a hard guy to trust.

  • There has been speculation among Bruce Bochy's friends around baseball that the Padres manager is worn down by losing and might not want to return. But Bochy has another season beyond this one, plus an option year, left on his contract. And GM Kevin Towers said, "He's not going anywhere."

    "We've had a tough year, but I don't see how anybody can think that's (Bochy's) fault," Towers said. "We just don't have a very good product right now. We're a young, inexperienced club. But I still think he's as good a manager as there is in the game, and we don't want anybody else."

    Yankees Rumblings
  • A friend of Junior Griffey tells Rumblings that after years of acting annoyed with the Yankees for throwing him out of the clubhouse when he was a kid, Griffey would now "love to go to the Yankees."

    But he can take a deep breath and go back to work, because clubs that have spoken with the Yankees say that's not happening and that Griffey's name has never come up in all their talk about adding a left-handed bat.

    The Yankees have told clubs they're willing to add no more than $1 million in payroll for whatever left-handed hitter they do add. But they haven't been real thrilled with the cast of "usual suspects" they've been offered -- a group that is believed to include John Vander Wal, Travis Lee and Matt Stairs.

    Gene Michael scouted Lee and Ben Grieve in Tampa Bay last weekend. But the Devil Rays reportedly aren't willing to pay most of Grieve's $5.25-million salary, even though Lou Piniella is said to be lobbying for dealing Grieve for a marginal prospect. And the Yankees are believed to be relatively unexcited about Grieve in the first place. With reason.

  • Elsewhere in the Yankees soap opera, don't paint a bull's-eye on Don Zimmer, just because he leaped to the defense of his friend, Joe Torre. A friend of Steinbrenner says the Boss just considered that to be "Zim being Zim." For now, it appears, no one in the Yankees coaching staff is in imminent danger. But winning four of five after Mount Steinbrenner erupted last week helped everybody's short-term job security.

  • An official of another club that has spoken with the Yankees says that Steinbrenner is getting frustrated with Nick Johnson's succession of injuries and has asked GM Brian Cashman to inquire around about what teams might be willing to offer for Johnson once he gets healthy. It seems very unlikely, however, that the baseball people will work up as much appetite for trading Johnson as their boss.
  • It comes around every few years, kind of like lunar eclipses and Carlos Reyes: Gary Sheffield closes in on the end of a contract and starts making noises about feeling unappreciated.

    He told the Atlanta Constitution's Dave O'Brien last week that if the Braves are planning to wait until he becomes a free agent this winter to negotiate, "that tells me you don't want me; simple as that."

    Really? Funny how the Braves let John Smoltz become a free agent but brought him back. They let Greg Maddux become a free agent but brought him back. They let Tom Glavine become a free agent and wanted to bring him back, too. So maybe it's just the way they do business -- and, in fact, have to do business right now.

    "We don't even know who's going to own our team," one Braves executive said. "We don't know what our leadership is going to be. So this is going to be the way it is. Hey, the guy's a good player, and he's playing great. We'd love to have him back. But right now, we have to wait and see -- about everything."

  • There have been indications over the last week that Bud Selig has told some of his cohorts at MLB that he's tired of waging war over QuesTec. How baseball ends that war is another matter.

    But in the meantime, if you find the Battle of QuesTec slightly mind-warping, join the club. We've had Curt Schilling bust up a QuesTec camera because he wasn't getting enough strikes called. And we've had Barry Bonds back Schilling, while saying his strike zone was getting too big.

    Sandy Alderson, MLB's executive VP for baseball operations, tells Rumblings he's no longer in the QuesTec debate club. But after Schilling's remarks, he did have the Elias Sports Bureau do some research. And Elias found that there was actually a slightly higher percentage of strikes called in parks that have QuesTec (31.6 percent) than in parks without it (31.0).

    "So if the notion," Alderson said, "is that more balls than strikes are being called in QuesTec parks, that's not accurate."

    Another interesting result of Elias' research was that the Diamondbacks were the only team with QuesTec in its home stadium that had a significantly better ERA on the road (3.53) than at home (4.66).

  • It's Year 8 in the life of the Devil Rays. And this will be their eighth straight losing season. But scouting directors and other executives we've surveyed still have no problem with Tampa Bay taking high school bopper Delmon Young with the first overall pick over college second baseman Rickie Weeks.

    "He may be a high school kid, but he's not that far away," said one GM. "This kid has a hell of a bat. The thing I don't understand is all the high school kids they took in the later rounds. (Tampa Bay didn't pick a college player until the seventh round.) The strength of this draft was college position players in the first four or five rounds. But I guess they're in no hurry (to be good)."

  • Two years ago, 15 of the 30 first-round picks in the June were college players. Last year, it was 14 of 30. This year, it was 18 of 30 -- the most since 1992. And several scouting directors predict that increasingly, college players will be the future of this draft -- as much because of money as "Moneyball."

    The cost of being wrong about a high school player is so high now that over the last couple of years, we've seen teams begin to draw the line over writing huge checks to all but the best of the high school crop. And that figures to drive more prospects than ever into playing college baseball.

    "Over time, if we continue on this course, this will be a more college-oriented draft," said Mike Arbuckle, the Phillies' assistant GM for player development and scouting. "The kids who we used to hand $500,000 to $700,000 to aren't going to get that kind of money in the future, for the most part. We've just reached the point where the industry in general can't afford to continue the spiral in bonuses for those kinds of kids.

    "So if 15 to 20 percent more kids who we consider to be some level of prospect now get funneled to college because of that, we're talking about a significant number of kids who play their three years in college and then go back into the draft."

    And baseball has seen that coming. So it reportedly has expressed a willingness to help pay the cost of wood bats in college baseball if either the major conferences or the NCAA is interested in pulling the plug on aluminum.

    "Major League Baseball is all for that," said one scouting director. "But we've got the power of the bat companies working against us. They've got those contracts with coaches, and their camps, and that's the biggest reason we're getting resistance."

  • Scouts who watched Troy Percival try to renovate his motion in the bullpen last week to take pressure off his hip were worried by what they saw.

    Percival
    Percival

    "He used to put a lot more body into it," said one scout. "Watching him, the torque he put on his shoulder looked uncomfortable to me. I wonder if he can make this radical an adjustment and, if he can, whether he might wind up hurting himself anyway."

    But it tells you how deep this bullpen is that the Angels could lose one of the five most reliable closers in the sport and still have possibly the best bullpen in the league.

    They have starting-pitching problems, but they don't have bullpen problems," said the same scout. "Brendan Donnelly was unbelievable. He topped out at 95 (mph) on his fastball and 88-90 on his slider. Scot Shields is throwing well. Ben Weber does a nice job. But Donnelly was absolutely incredible."

  • The theory on why the White Sox are doomed to firing Jerry Manuel is that they're a team built to win this year. But GM Kenny Williams has a different spin.

    "I said prior to opening day that this team is built for the long haul," Williams said. "We're built for more than just a couple of years. So I felt, with all our young guys, it wasn't as imperative for us to start out of the gate fast."

    Williams acknowledges that his team is feeling the pressure to turn it around. But his theory is that sooner or later, they'll acknowledge they've hit rock bottom, and that might be "just the point we need to get to."

    "We need to say, the heck with it," Williams said. "We've got to wipe the slate clean -- or it's going to be a long summer. But I'm prepared to stick by these guys, because I believe in the talent."

    That talent, on paper, still looks good. But one AL scout who has seen a lot of the White Sox calls them "a dysfunctional team."

  • Every indication is that the sale of the Dodgers to the Glazer family is now on baseball's fast track.

  • Lou Piniella is living up to his reputation in Tampa Bay in more ways than one. Never known for his laid-back handling of pitchers, Piniella has changed his rotation every week since the third week of the season.

    "I've seen them three times," said one scout, "and they've had a different rotation all three times. I'm covering their minor-league system -- by seeing their major-league staff."

    Jayson Stark is a senior writer for ESPN.com.





  •  More from ESPN...
    Jayson Stark home page
    Catch all the Rumblings & ...

    Vote: Interleague Play, like it or not
    SportsNation: Yankees vs. ...

    Jayson Stark Archive



     ESPN Tools
    Email story
     
    Most sent
     
    Print story
     
    Daily email