![]() | |
![]() |
| Friday, January 18 Updated: January 23, 3:54 PM ET Oakland Athletics By John Sickels Special to ESPN.com |
||||||||||||||||||
2001 in review
What went wrong
In retrospect, the critical decisions were: 2. When rookie second baseman Jose Ortiz got off to a slow, injury-plagued start, Oakland replaced him with minor-league vet Frankie Menechino. Many teams would have picked up a "proven" (and expensive) veteran to handle second, but Menechino held his own, drawing 79 walks, and doing it cheaply. He cooled as the season progressed and is not a long-term solution, but did fine work as a stopgap. 3. Using Cory Lidle, another player derided as a "non prospect" by many experts, in the starting rotation. He went 13-6 with a 3.59 ERA. 4. Adopting an organization-wide emphasis on plate discipline, strike zone judgment, and baseball skills, and sticking with it even when things didn't go as planned right away.
Looking ahead to 2002 2. Outfield questions. How quickly will Dye recover from his broken leg? Can Long play center field? 3. Billy Koch replaces Isringhausen as the closer. While Koch is "proven," he had some command problems last year, and will need to improve on his 4.80 ERA.
Can expect to play better
Can expect to play worse
Projected lineup
Rotation
Closer
A closer look There is no question that it is harder for a team with less money to compete, but having lots of dough is no guarantee of success. No one disputes that it will be more difficult for the Athletics to compete over the long haul than, say, the Yankees. But money is not enough. Success in baseball is all about resource deployment. Oakland has won because they use their resources wisely. Other teams lose because they use their resources poorly. "Being Oakland, we have to try and load the percentages in our favor," says Athletics GM Billy Beane. While the loss of Jason Giambi and Jason Isringhausen to free agency would have been a crippling blow to some organizations, Beane is not deterred. "I'm happy with what we've been able to do. We've got the best first-base prospect (Carlos Pena) in the game to replace Jason (Giambi), and we replaced Izzy with another good closer in (Billy) Koch." Beane credits the work done by the farm-system managers, coaches, and scouts in keeping the system afloat. "We were able to make the trade with the Rangers because we were dealing from a position of strength. (Mario) Ramos is a great prospect, but we already have good left-handed pitching. The Rangers needed a pitcher, we needed a first baseman, it was a good fit for both teams. We couldn't do things like that if the farm system wasn't strong." Oakland has been over .500 for three years now, and despite the free-agent defections, they should be well over .500 again in 2002. Here's a look at them by position.
Catcher Hernandez is showing gradual improvement, and is just entering his prime at age 26. No reason to expect a downturn at this position, and he may improve further. Stays the same.
First Base Pena won't post a 1.137 OPS or challenge for the MVP award, but he should hit .275-.285 with 20+ homers, lots of walks, and solid defense, plus he is seven years younger than Giambi. A short-term decline at this position, but the drop-off will be less than people imagine, especially in the long run.
Second Base Menechino did good work last year, but slumped in the second half and is not the long-term solution. He will vie with re-signed vet Velarde to play the position in '02, though prospect Esteban German (a tremendous speed/patience player) is on their heels. Should stay the same.
Third Base Continues to steadily improve, and at age 24 it seems unlikely that this will stop. Should improve slightly if he maintains a normal growth curve.
Shortstop His '01 season was actually a bit weaker than his '00 campaign. Age 26, and likely another candidate to improve slightly.
Outfield Long seems likely to move to center field to replace Damon. Even if Long just does what he did last year, it will be an upgrade over the season produced by Damon, at least with the bat. There are concerns about his defense in center. There is some speculation that prospect Byrnes could play center, with Long handling left field, but that remains to be seen. Balancing hitting, defense, and growth considerations, the outfield looks to be about the same overall as it was last year. Stays the same.
Bench/DH Again, this doesn't look any weaker than in '02 than in '01, and could even be better. Should stay the same.
Rotation No change in personnel, so there is no roster deterioration to point at. As mentioned above, it would not be surprising if at least one of these guys struggled in 2002, because of injuries or just the nature of the pitching craft. But from a talent perspective, it stays the same.
Bullpen Koch was less effective than Izzy last year, but the Athletics believe they can turn him around. Holtz replaces Guthrie, pretty much a wash, and the rest of the staff returns. There is probably more unpredictability here than at any other nexus on the roster. Koch could be brilliant, but he could also be awful. My gut instinct is that the bullpen will decline slightly next year. Even if Koch pitches well, the middle-relief corps could backslide. Basically, Oakland is in the same condition it was last year at catcher, second base, the outfield, the bench, and the rotation. Third base and shortstop should improve slightly, which will be offset by declines at first base and possibly the bullpen, though the dropoff at both shouldn't be catastrophic. No, this does not mean that Oakland will win 102 games again. Too many things have to go right for that to happen, but unless they get hit with a rash of injuries, they should be in the 90-95 win range and the wild-card hunt once again. In other words, they will continue to compete, despite their financial restrictions. John Sickels is working on the 2002 STATS Minor League Scouting Notebook. He lives in Lawrence, Kansas, with his wife, son, and two cats. You can send John questions or comments at JASickels@aol.com, or you can visit his homepage at hometown.aol.com/jasickels/page1.html. |
|
|||||||||||||||||